Quote:
|
What this film needs is a deluxe two- (or three-) disc-er that includes not only the "Director's Cut", but also the original theatrical version, which many fans, including this one, prefer.
|
The first (cream border) and second (Film Noir line) VHS tapes from Universal were of the 1975 re-cut which added 12 minutes to the film. I don't think the 1958 version has ever been on video. I'd imagine it hasn't been in theatrical circulation since 1975, either.
To be honest, if the restored version of the film is a great film, I don't know how the previous versions would be superior in any way.
I'm guessing the argument over aspect ratio (Academy vs. 1.85:1) is bunk after reading Jack Theakston's post on This Island Earth. It definately looks like a 1.85:1 film, regardless of the cramped logo.
Criterion REALLY needs this film, though. Remaster the film in a new HD transfer, include the restored version, the 1958 theatrical cut, and the 1975 partial restoration. Add back the commentary, making-of documentary, a Peter Bogdanovich intro, the original and restoration trailers, and the memo in PDF form. One can never have too much Welles.
By the way, Amazon.com has this for $9.99.