[Danny Tse]

Shania Twain w/ Alison Krauss and Union Station

or

Celine Dion, Anastacia and Meredith Brooks

[ChristopherG]

While I find Celine Dion all kinds of irritating I would say that version.

Both, however, border on blasphemy...

[Marc Colella]

I'd say the Shania Twain one only because it tries to be different (a country twist to the song) and has Alison Krauss. Not a fan of Shania's singing though.

Celine Dion's version doesn't do anything different really except exponentially suck, and the fact that Celine Dion is singing is never a good thing.

That said, not a fan of either myself. Truth be told, I'm sick of hearing the original as well.

[Carl Miller]

Neither. They're both just so very wrong.

[Greg_S_H]

I'm about with Marc. I don't like either cover, and the original is getting a little rickety. I've seen two reactions to the Dion cover. Some think it's earbleedingly bad and a horrible joke. Others say, "I don't like Celine Dion, but it's a pretty decent, straightforward cover." I say, I don't want to ever have to hear it again.

[Ron Reda]

I thought Maroon 5 also covered this in concert...

[Joe_H]

How about the cover by Six Feet Under?

[Kirk Gunn]

Along the same lines of this thread, I once sampled a few tunes off a Bluegrass band's cover of Van Halen. Some weren't too bad.....

[Aaron Silverman]

There was a whole album of bluegrass Van Halen covers recently -- I think David Lee Roth was involved.

Some Bluegrass is good stuff, unlike that colorless pop that passes for most "Country" music these days.

[Mike<R]

I think I would rather take any of the Final Destination deaths than either one of those covers.