Quadrophenia coming to DVD-A!!!!!!

Justin Lane · 09-24-2003, 02:59 PM

Acording to Musictap, Pete T is working on a new multichannel mix for a release of Quadrophenia to DVD-A. Great news as it looks like DVD-A is really picking up the superstar artists.

J

Note: A seperate SACD release was mentioned as well as a possibility

Justin Lane · 09-24-2003, 03:04 PM

Noticed this was mentioned in the following thread as well as part of the Who news.

http://www.hometheaterforum.com/htfo...hreadid=160640

Mods, Please keep this thread open, as it pertains specifically to the DVD-A release and the momentum that is really beginning to build behind the format in the music community. Grassroots at its best.

J

Emil Stoica · 09-24-2003, 09:23 PM

Well considering that Universal Europe just decided to go SACD only and drop all future DVD-A releases, I guess the USA is the only place for that momentum.

Glad it will be available on both formats.

Justin Lane · 09-24-2003, 10:49 PM

Quote:

Well considering that Universal Europe just decided to go SACD only and drop all future DVD-A releases, I guess the USA is the only place for that momentum.

I missed this announcement....source please?

J

Justin Lane · 09-24-2003, 10:49 PM

What, no Who fans excited by this news?

J

**HTF Ads**

Jesper · 09-25-2003, 10:49 AM

I will get this for sure!

DVD Audio version...

Emil Stoica · 09-25-2003, 11:51 PM

Justin,

It is in the October issue of a germany audio magazine called STEREO. They have a website (www.stereo.de) but they are very slow on updates.

In a nutshell, they decided to cease production of DVD-A in Europe. And as you know from past posts, I own both. Just thought your choice of emphasis in the first post was ironic considering.....

Justin Lane · 09-26-2003, 09:30 AM

Quote:

It is in the October issue of a germany audio magazine called STEREO. They have a website (www.stereo.de) but they are very slow on updates.

Oh, I saw the threads over on AA as well.

It would be hard for Universal to cease production of DVD-A in Europe when they have not even started!!!

The gist of the article was that the president of Universal Germany (not Europe) said the people over there should be supporting SACD and buying SACD compatible players. I am not sure where you got the idea that production of DVD-A has ceased across Europe however?

Quote:

In a nutshell, they decided to cease production of DVD-A in Europe. And as you know from past posts, I own both. Just thought your choice of emphasis in the first post was ironic considering.....

Here in the United States, it seems to be going the opposite way with Universal. They are beginning to embrace the DVD-A audio format realizing it gives access to surround music for those people without Hi-res players, as well as adding the bonus feature not possible on SACD, which have helped DVD-V become as successful as it is today. Different trends in different countires I guess.

J

Justin Lane · 09-26-2003, 09:33 AM

Quote:

I will get this for sure! DVD Audio version...

Thats the one I plan on picking up. There should be some very interesting bonus features along with improved sound quality since the disc is most likely being mixed in PCM at a minimum for the surround track.

J

LarryDavenport · 09-26-2003, 11:49 AM

Besides the video content, why do you guys think DVD-A is better than SAVD? I have a Universal player so I can play both, but I don't want to buy a copy for each format.

Justin Lane · 09-26-2003, 12:48 PM

Quote:

Besides the video content, why do you guys think DVD-A is better than SAVD? I have a Universal player so I can play both, but I don't want to buy a copy for each format.

My one problem with many SACD is that they use PCM sources converted to DSD (Sony's new royalty..err I mean sampling scheme) to place the content on the disc. This extra coversion changes what we are hearing from the original master (albeit very slightly).

DVD-A avoids this additional conversion by giving us the PCM recorded material just as the artist intended, and is present on the original masters. Most music today (even much of what Sony puts onto SACD themselves) is still first recorded as PCM and then converted. Before DSD, almost all music over the past 20-25 years digitally recorded, was PCM in nature.

Now where DSD can shine and almost equal PCM (24/192, 24/96) is in brand new recordings (not much in mainstream category here yet) and transfers of older analog masters (>25 years old). Still, even in many of these transfers from analog to DSD, PCM is used in the editing stages (at high frequencies of course).

Are you beginning to see pattern here. Sony creates a new sampling scheme, DSD to be used on SACD, a possible replacement for the lost stream of CD royalties. They market DSD as great, and PCM as evil, yet PCM is intimately involved many SACD. Makes one wonder....

These SACD from PCM sources many times sound great, as the masters used are better than CD qualty. Still, being an audio enthusiast, I want my music as close to the master tapes as possible. When it comes to PCM recordings, DVD-A is the best option at this point of time.

J