Patrick Sun

A Good Year - quick review

I had a real good time with this film (regardless of the lukewarm reviews it's getting from the critics), and there is such a charm and light touch to the humor and spirit that evolves out of this tale featuring Max (A reteaming of Russell Crowe and Ridley Scott featuring a lead character named Max, what were the odds of that?), a lead stock/bond manager in England with a snarky competitive bent, who comes to learn that making money isn't everything in life after he returns to his now deceased uncle's French chateau (Max was the only living known relative at the time of death, and thus inherited the chateau as there were no changes in his will for over 20 years) with the primary purpose to sell off the property, but encounters not only the fond memories of his childhood spent at the chateau, but re-discovers the worth of love and simply living from moment to moment.

Ridley Scott amazes me with not only the breadth of films he's done in his career, but the deftness he shows with each genre. This film had some terrific pacing, and its 2 hour running time just flew by, with many funny bits interspersed from a colorful cast of characters that were fleshed out enough to be believable in their words and actions.

I give this film 3 stars, or a grade of B.

"I am a leaf on the wind, watch how I soar!"
Patcave | 2006 Films | 2007 Films | Dragon Con 2007

Chad R

Re: A Good Year - quick review

Sorry, I agree with the critics. It's a tired rehash of several other mid-life crises movies of the past. From the moment it started you knew how it would end. Sometimes that's okay so long as the ride is fun, but this ride was lifeless. Much of it felt like a discussion on real estate. Any attempts at twists didn't elicit a "how will this effect things?" reaction, but rather a "oh, so that's going to end up this way" assumption which is proven right.

"If you write a story about a soldier going AWOL and kidnapping a pregnant woman and finally shooting her in the head, it's called searingly realistic, even though it's never happened in the history of mankind. Whereas if you write about two people falling in love, which happens about a million times a day all over the world, for some reason or another, you're accused of writing something unrealistic and sentimental."
-Richard Curtis, Screenwriter and Director

Carlo Medina

Re: A Good Year - quick review

I'm still going to see this film (or get it on DVD) because of my recent experience in France, which mirrored a lot of what is shown on the trailer (especially the "They're BOTH D3!!!" scene) While making nowhere near the money Crowe's character does, I found myself drawn to the simpler way of life that I was exposed to in the small villages in the south of France.

I'm a Ridley fan, and I don't mind Crowe (especially when he's not in fistfights or throwing phones), so I think I stand a good chance at enjoying this.

Patrick Sun

Re: A Good Year - quick review

I liked it because it had a more contempory Euro-flavor to the storytelling, not an American one. It was more about mood, feelings, and discovery, not really a plot-driven film filled with twists, but rather just obstacles to figuring out the good life.

"I am a leaf on the wind, watch how I soar!"
Patcave | 2006 Films | 2007 Films | Dragon Con 2007

Tim Glover

Re: A Good Year - quick review

Quote:

Originally Posted by Patrick Sun I liked it because it had a more contempory Euro-flavor to the storytelling, not an American one. It was more about mood, feelings, and discovery, not really a plot-driven film filled with twists, but rather just obstacles to figuring out the good life.

Saw this last night and agree with Patrick's comments.

At first and really the first 30 minutes or so, I was thinking this was kind of strange and even awkward at times? But it's a nice film that does take some time to get to you and I enjoyed it. Crowe is rather effective at all kinds of acting roles it seems. Albert Finney was great too.

Really loved "Gemma". She was such a smarty pants and made me smile watching her.

It certainly has a Euro flavor throughout.

Pleasant film that does have a nice message.

8/10.

May 25, 1977