[Bill Huelbig]

The Variety review is not so good (and contains spoilers):

http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117...goryId=31&cs=1

Quotation of entire review deleted by moderator. See HTF Rule 10. - MR

[Magnus T]

It's Todd McCarthy. He hates everything.

[RobertR]

The New Republic blasted it:

http://www.tnr.com/user/nregi.mhtml?...=diarist121905

The article is not atypical of criticism of Spielberg in general.

[MikeRS]

David Ansen put it in his top ten of the year (#8)

Newsweek

Quotation of entire review deleted by moderator. See HTF Rule 10. - MR

[Tino]

Quote:

It's Todd McCarthy. He hates everything.

Not everything. He loved King Kong.

[MikeRS]

Hollywood Reporter gave it high marks.

Quotation of entire review deleted by moderator. See HTF Rule 10. - MR

[Chris Atkins]

Quote:

Not everything. He loved King Kong.

And ROTS too.

[TheLongshot]

Jeff Wells didn't like it either.

Jason

[Kyle_D]

Quote:

Jeff Wells didn't like it either.

Not true. He said it was a perfectly good movie that was still hanging with him the day after he saw it. He just didn't think it was an Oscar contender and has been hilighting the negative responses in his blog.

[MikeRS]

Washington Area Film Critics gave Spielberg and Munich top honors. First critics group to do so.

Will it be the only one.....