Why aren't Eddie M, Steve M, Robin W. funny anymore?

Matthew Prince · 08-04-2004, 01:07 PM

Hi!

I've always wanted to ask: Why aren't Eddie Murphy, Steve Martin and Robin Williams funny anymore?

It seems that each of the comedies have slid into middle age and just lost their flair! Ironically, they only seem to be funny when their doing voiceovers!

I mean why is Eddie very funny doing the voice of Donkey in Shrek 2, but awful in Haunted Mansion, Pluto Nash and Daddy Day Care? The last 'live-action' movie where he was funny was in Nutty Professor 1!

Steve Martin gave us The Jerk, Man With Two Brains, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels and even LA Story. But nowadays... he seems to get worse and worse what with Cheaper By The Dozen (cringe!) and Briniging Down The House (horrifying!

) I read interviews with him around the Net that he's really more interested in writing comedy, dramas and stage plays more than anything else, and if that's true, then STEVE, Quit acting! Go out on top! There's no shame in moving into writing, producing and directing!

Robin Williams... ahh... Mr Saccharine... He's given us Aladdin, but Jack. Mrs Doubtfire!, but Hook AND Bicentennial Man AND Jakob The Liar AND Patch Adams... He managed to redeem himself with the stand up show he done for DVD. 100 mins of 'off the cuff' unrehearsed and ad-libbed humour! So he's still got it, but why is he seen in such mawkish and sentimental movies?

My suggestions, at least, for Eddie are to do a couple of R-Rated comedies where he can run his mouth and truly be HIMSELF. It's all well and good making family movies for the kids, but Eddie is forgetting the older fans! We wanna see some of the old Eddie, the trash-talking Eddie, the take-no-s%£t Eddie! He NEEDS to hook up with Paramount again and give us some more FUN movies, like some sequels (Coming to America, Trading Places, 48 Hours?) new projects (bring back Arsenio!) and a NEW Stand Up movie! It's about time!

I don't know what to suggest for Steve Martin and Robin Williams. Has anybody got any ideas?

todd stone · 08-04-2004, 01:35 PM

Quote:

Steve Martin gave us The Jerk, Man With Two Brains, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels and even LA Story. But nowadays... he seems to get worse and worse what with Cheaper By The Dozen (cringe!) and Briniging Down The House (horrifying! ) I read interviews with him around the Net that he's really more interested in writing comedy, dramas and stage plays more than anything else, and if that's true, then STEVE, Quit acting! Go out on top! There's no shame in moving into writing, producing and directing!

Let's not forget Planes, Trains and Automobiles

Vince Maskeeper · 08-04-2004, 01:38 PM

Lack of Cocaine?

ElAhrai · 08-04-2004, 01:41 PM

Well to answer your last question first, I think both Martin and Williams seem to be doing really well in darker movies (such as One Hour Photo or Novocaine).

As for why they seem to be drifting from comedy in general, part of it has to do with the idea that many comedians use comedy to deal with anger. So if they have less to be angry about, then they have less to be funny about too.

And while I'd love to see them all return to something like their earlier work but many times I've heard actors say that they want to do something that their kids will enjoy, and so we get the more "family friendly" stuff.

Ken_McAlinden · 08-04-2004, 02:14 PM

Steve Martin is still funny when he wants to be. He seems to be willing to either play the straight man (Cheaper by the Dozen), play the goofball, (Looney Tunes Back in Action) or straddle the line (Bringing Down the House), which probably keeps him from getting bored. He also was good in a non-comedic supporting role in "The Spanish Prisoner" several years ago, so he has acting options. Eddie Murphy seems to be playing more or less the same guy quite frequently even though he made his bones creating characters on SNL.

Robin Williams has been going dark lately with One Hour Photo, Insomnia, and ...ugh... Death to Smoochy all coming out since the films listed in the initial post. He hasn't had a particularly sentimental role since Bicentennial Man in 1999.

Speaking of Martin and Murphy, I actualy think that the "Bowfinger" film that they made about five years ago was the funniest film either of them have made in quite awhile, but it wasn't a big box office hit.

Regards,

**HTF Ads**

Malcolm R · 08-04-2004, 02:22 PM

Steve Martin is playing Clouseau in "The Pink Panther" remake, so I assume he'll be funny in that (or at least try).

Lou Sytsma · 08-04-2004, 02:34 PM

They've become housebroken.

MatthewA · 08-04-2004, 03:43 PM

I agree that Bowfinger was a pretty good movie.

But perhaps they feel they can't top their past successes and just want to work anyway.

Mike Graham · 08-04-2004, 03:56 PM

Its hard to say if any studio will invest in R-rated comedys these days. While they were plentiful in the 80's, they really seem to have died out in this day age.

Holadem · 08-04-2004, 04:05 PM

Aiii... these days of There is something about Mary, American Pie(3), Scary Movies(3)?

--
H

Mike Graham · 08-04-2004, 04:14 PM

Yes, but those are the exception -- looking back it seems like every movie in the 80s was rated R !