2004 Film List - Page 17

Adam_S · 08-18-2005, 02:43 PM

Ray -

08/17/2005
OAR-HDHBO-DVR

There's been some criticism lain against the movie that you don't learn anything about Ray Charles, but I think you do. I think you learn that the most important thing to him was not his music, was not his family, was not his drugs, it was not being considered a cripple that was the driving force of his life. Jamie Foxx is outstanding to watch and the music is just utterly wonderful to listen to.

If there's a quibble I have with the movie, it's that I don't know if Ray Charles was Mozart and wrote everything perfectly the first time or whether he struggled as most mere mortals do.

I love that we get the background on his childhood when the personality is really formed and which is often neglected, but it was very well used here.

I didn't feel the film was overlong, I did feel it's got about four acts instead of three and that it could have used about a twenty minute fifth act to cover what a few titles did, because the movie just ends without an acceptable coda to ease you out of its spell.

In terms of sheer enjoyment I felt this was one of the best of the year and I'll be updating my top ten list.

Adam

Adam_S · 08-18-2005, 02:48 PM

Here's my new top ten list, and personally I think ten is too few for these lists cause twenty is much more flexible number. what if number 1 got 10 points and number 20 got .5 points. It'd work very happily for me.

1. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
The Passion of the Christ
The Incredibles
Finding Neverland
In Good Company
The Aviator
Closer
Ray
Million Dollar Baby
Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

Seth Paxton · 08-30-2005, 09:36 AM

I like that you put Lemony Snicket up there. I agree with you. Watching it again on DVD only reinforced my feelings on that film. Incredible art direction, strong fanciful children's story with that dangerous edge that kids films used to have on a more regular basis. I had it at 19th, but as you mentioned my top 20 also contains all 9+ films and on the year I would consider about 25 films to have been outstanding work devoid of any serious flaws (or artistically ambitious enough to make up for them).

Alfie
5 of 10
The main problem with the film is that it just feels "Hollywoodized". All the script turns feel like any number of romantic comedy plotlines, and while the direction attempts to inject moments of artistry into the storytelling (like a series of stills used to tell a subplot) it isn't enough, nor is it consistent throughout the film.

Too much of the film is also compartmentalized so that you get 100 small bites rather than a nice, flowing film. The result is that it drags along and starts to bore. In fact those artistic flares feel more like attempts to jump start the pace that have been patched on rather than being integral to the storytelling.

Bill McA · 09-04-2005, 01:35 PM

Updated my List with:

Napoleon Dynamite
Ae Fond Kiss...
November
Wilby Wonderful
We Don't Live Here Anymore
Sucker Free City
Riding Giants
SuperBabies: Baby Geniuses 2
Shake Hands with the Devil: The Journey of Roméo Dallaire
Criminal
Troy

Cory H. · 09-04-2005, 10:40 PM

2004 Films (44 Theatre Trips)

Blade: Trinity

Bubba Ho-Tep

Butterfly Effect, The

Chronicles of Riddick, The

1/2
Collateral

Dawn of the Dead (x 2)

Day After Tomorrow, The

Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story

Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind

Friday Night Lights

Godsend

Grudge, The

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

HellBoy

Hero

I, Robot

Incredibles, The

King Arthur

Manchurian Candidate, The

Man On Fire

Monster

Napoleon Dynamite

National Treasure

Ocean's Twelve

1/2
Passion Of The Christ, The

Punisher, The

Resident Evil: Apocalypse

1/2
Saw

Spider-Man 2 (x 2)

1/2
Shaun of the Dead (x 3)

Shrek 2

Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow

Starsky & Hutch

1/2
Stepford Wives, The

Taking Lives

1/2
Win a Date with Tad Hamilton

Seth Paxton · 09-09-2005, 08:28 PM

Mr. 3000
6 of 10
It's a lot of implausible formula and runs along the template most of the time. But somehow for me Bernie Mac raises it with his humor and sincerity. He's pretty solid at being both likeable and dislikable at the same time.

Seth Paxton · 09-15-2005, 01:33 AM

Cellular
6 of 10
There are many parts that are really corny, but somehow the pace and the sometimes smart moments keep in just entertaining enough to be an okay time. It's far off the level of the recent similar popcorn style thriller "Red Eye" however.

Beyond the Sea
7.5 of 10
Nicely directed, mostly well acted especially by Spacey, but not so well written. Some parts are nice, other parts are pushy and hack like the awkward beginning. It's a mix of impressive and disappointing work from Spacey, but it leans more toward the impressive end. Certainly the true story was pretty interesting stuff.

Seth Paxton · 10-30-2005, 11:24 AM

Blade Trinity
4 of 10
Most of the time it felt like it was being phoned in. A few good action sequences and the humor of Ryan Reynolds were about the only decent things in the film. I guess the character of Blade is just interesting enough to me to keep this above a 2 or 3, but I can understand how others would hate the film.

Meet the Fockers
7.5 of 10
I think I liked the dynamic of having adult foils to DeNiro's character more than the bumbling Stiller from the first film. Having Streisand and Hoffman to challenge DeNiro turned the tables and provided a better comedy for me.

Phantom of the Opera
6.5 of 10
Eh, looked okay but it had less spark than seeing it live and much of the best moments were directly from the musical. Schumacher added absolutely nothing here, diluted some moments with his style, and then let the film version just run way too long. I also didn't think Butler was up to the challenge of playing the Phantom.

The dynamics and energy that push musicals like Moulin Rouge, Chicago or Hedwig are totally absent here.

Kung Fu Hustle
8 of 10
Honestly the trailers made me question the sanity of people who said the film was great and truly funny. But it turned out that they were right. Yes there were some CGI moments (mostly involving speed running) that were corny, but the film is a wonderful bit of character work in which every turn brings about some new inventive personality to entertain, and that was the film's strength.

It was creative and cute and worth seeing more than once. I rented it but it's lingered on my mind enough to consider buying it.

These put me to 87 2004 films viewed, 40 at the theater.