Our Top 10's of 2002 -- Time To Throw Down / The HTF 2002 Film Awards (See Post #1) - Page 4

Brook K · 02-17-2003, 03:16 AM

No changes to top 10's. I've up to 47 watched and 20 of the top 30.

Arman · 02-17-2003, 11:35 PM

Dana Fillhart · 02-18-2003, 01:15 PM

Just thought I'd get an update out there...
Not much has changed, just some film totals, mostly.

The Top 30 of Our Top 10 of 2002
Contributing, Qualifying Members: 77
Includes all member updates through 18 Feb 2003 2 PM

#

Title

Total Score

Fractional Weighted Total

Top 10 List Appearances :
2002 Film List Appearances

Weighted Average

Unweighted Average

01

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers

369

41.60

51 : 60

7.24

4.79

02

Minority Report

278

33.60

44 : 58

6.32

3.61

03

Punch-Drunk Love

265

32.16

39 : 50

6.79

3.44

04

Gangs of New York

199.5

24.60

34 : 51

5.87

2.59

05

Adaptation.

199

25.28

30 : 39

6.63

2.58

06

Sen to Chihiro no kamikakushi (Spirited Away)

173

21.36

25 : 32

6.92

2.25

07

Bowling for Columbine

165

20.14

24 : 37

6.88

2.14

08

Chicago

160

19.85

26 : 36

6.15

2.08

09

Road to Perdition

125

16.68

23 : 45

5.43

1.62

10

The Pianist

120

15.58

19 : 24

6.32

1.56

11

Signs

116

15.71

22 : 48

5.27

1.51

12

Y Tu Mamá También (And Your Mother Too)

98

13.61

18 : 38

5.44

1.27

13

About Schmidt

91.5

12.23

18 : 36

5.08

1.19

14

Catch Me If You Can

85

13.06

17 : 40

5.00

1.10

15

Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones

83

9.54

14 : 47

5.93

1.08

16

Solaris

80

11.44

14 : 31

5.71

1.04

17

25th Hour

77

12.06

16 : 28

4.81

1.00

18

Far from Heaven

74

8.77

13 : 30

5.69

0.96

19

Insomnia

66

8.90

13 : 44

5.08

0.86

20

Frailty

66

9.43

14 : 41

4.71

0.86

21

The Hours

63

9.44

12 : 23

5.25

0.82

22

Metropolis

57

9.10

10 : 26

5.70

0.74

23

Hable con Ella (Talk to Her)

47

7.40

08 : 13

5.88

0.61

24

Changing Lanes

42

5.65

07 : 35

6.00

0.55

25

Thirteen Conversations About One Thing

42

7.40

09 : 30

4.67

0.55

26

About a Boy

38

6.83

10 : 32

3.80

0.49

27

Spider-Man

38

7.28

12 : 46

3.17

0.49

28

The Ring

37

4.71

08 : 35

4.63

0.48

29

Panic Room

36

4.74

08 : 43

4.50

0.47

30

Igby Goes Down

34

4.48

06 : 22

5.67

0.44

Columns:

Position
Film Title
Total Score: A summation of each film's position in each contributor's top 10, with points given as follows: 1st place = 10, 10th place = 1. 10th place ties get .5 points per tie, limit to 2. All ties above 10th place get full points in each position, so long as the total points for the contributor does not exceed 55 (10+9+...+1); if that happens, remainder of tie will be divided like they were 10th place.
Fractional Weighted Total: The total combined fractional weighted scores of each contributor's film. Fractional weighted scores are computed for each contributor by the position of the film against the total number of films seen -- i.e., if a contributor saw 50 films, 1st place is 50/50 (1.00), 10th place is 41/50 (0.82). This gives more weight to lists with higher film totals.
Top 10 List Appearances : 2002 Film List Appearances: Ratio of a film's appearance in this thread to how many appearances it makes in contributors' lists in the 2002 Film List thread. This gives better value to the Weighted Average (and Total Score) numbers.
Weighted Average: Total Score divided by Top 10 List Appearances. This is considered weighted because it only takes into account those contributors who have the film in the top 10.
Unweighted Average: Total Score divided by total number of Top 10 contributors (currently 77).

Contributing members (if your name is not on here, and you are sure your list is complete, email me. Grey numbers beside names denotes less than 35 -- if you have only those listed here in the Top 10 list, then you didn't post a list in the 2002 Film List):

(30/30 : 232) Jason Whyte
(27/30 : 172) Stephen R
(29/30 : 295) Bill Harris
(15/30 : 058) Matthew Chmiel
(28/30 : 130) Kevin Leonard
(30/30 : 117) Edwin Pereyra
(17/30 : 048) Matt Stone
(23/30 : 079) John Thomas
(06/30 : 010) Justin_S
(14/30 : 037) Travis_S
(08/30 : 011) Adam_S
(08/30 : 010) Doug R
(18/30 : 077) Derik Miner
(25/30 : 075) Jehan
(23/30 : 045) Rob Willey
(13/30 : 133) JohnS
(04/30 : 010) Doug D
(30/30 : 277) Michael Perez
(25/30 : 242) Scott Weinberg
(07/30 : 010) Dean DeMass

(26/30 : 086) Craig S
(20/30 : 069) John Spencer
(28/30 : 104) Kristian
(26/30 : 111) Chris_Richard
(16/30 : 064) ChuckDeLa
(18/30 : 137) Ruth_F
(06/30 : 010) Joel Turpin
(04/30 : 010) L. Anton Dencklau
(08/30 : 010) Dustin Woods
(07/30 : 010) AaronJB
(21/30 : 087) Nick Sievers
(07/30 : 010) Steve Lockwood
(27/30 : 196) Jason Seaver
(00/30 : 010) Brian Lawrence
(24/30 : 069) NickNC
(09/30 : 010) Larry Sutliff
(15/30 : 043) Bill J
(04/30 : 010) Rob P S
(30/30 : 133) Kirk Tsai
(07/30 : 010) Dome Vongvises

(08/30 : 010) Kami
(21/30 : 054) Lowell_B
(05/30 : 010) Damin J Toell
(09/30 : 010) Paul Case
(15/30 : 054) Scott_MacD
(16/30 : 063) Joshua_Y
(25/30 : 064) Dana Fillhart
(04/30 : 010) Malcom R
(08/30 : 010) JonZ
(08/30 : 010) PatrickL
(27/30 : 216) Mark Pfeiffer
(13/30 : 057) Andrew Schwarz
(09/30 : 010) JonBoriss
(08/30 : 010) MikeRS
(09/30 : 010) Steven Lay
(09/30 : 010) Pat Ford
(09/30 : 010) Fred Bang
(13/30 : 034) Chuck Mayer
(04/30 : 010) Martin Fontaine
(10/30 : 010) Paul-Gunther

(10/30 : 010) Kevin Clemons
(06/30 : 010) Elizabeth S
(27/30 : 059) Arman
(03/30 : 010) JonathanG
(07/30 : 010) Marc_Savoie
(10/30 : 010) Barry Woodward
(09/30 : 010) LawrenceK
(08/30 : 010) Chris Harvey
(19/30 : 139) Mark Palermo
(08/30 : 010) Michael Costa
(05/30 : 010) steve jaros
(27/30 : 092) Seth Paxton
(26/30 : 098) Eric Howell
(06/30 : 011) Quentin
(20/30 : 047) Brook K
(07/30 : 010) Vickie_M
(08/30 : 010) Winston Smith

Non-qualifying members:

Declan, LennyP - List can only contain 2002 FILMS (there were a few other people with one or two platform-pushover titles, which I've let go for the time being)
Angelo.M - Must have 10 titles in the list, and at least 35 seen from 2002
Luc D - You'll need an order to your list)

MichaelPe · 02-19-2003, 05:44 PM

Dana,
I guess it's just a typo, but shouldn't Bill Harris have 302 movies next to his name (and 30/30 films seen)? After all, he is the "2002 List Leader".

Dana Fillhart · 02-20-2003, 08:33 AM

Michael,

I've mentioned it a few times, but it never hurts to repeat it

Lots of members have TWO lists in their 2002 Film List (myself included) -- one alphabetically, one by rating, and sometimes one by date seen. Often there are discrepancies between the two lists.

In Bill Harris' case, I literally copied and pasted his *RATING* list, because that list required less editing on my part -- if I had grabbed his alphabetical list, I'd have to manually go through every title and get rid of his extraneous information. True to the Programmer's Credo, I took the lazier route

Once I have a member's full list of titles, I go through them and ensure each title matches the "standard" title (i.e., "Hable con Ella (Talk to Her)" instead of just "Talk to Her"). I toyed with the idea of having a master list of films, and just having a 1 or a 0 in each row, going across the columns for each member. You'd think that'd be programmatically easier, but it turns out to be a nightmare for updates -- when members update their lists, there is no consistency in how they do it, so I have to manually go through the lists for each "Last edited by" that fits the dates I'm looking for, and pick out each new title, and add it to the spreadsheet. Doing it by name is surprisingly (or maybe not so surprisingly) FAR faster than if there was one master list of titles and "checking off" if the person has seen it.

For the 2003 titles, I eventually plan on having a website that members can come to and check off which ones they've seen, and get an HTML output of their choosing to insert in the 2002 Film List thread. Due to interfering influences (read: my day job

), that's been put on a back burner temporarily, but I hope to get it started this weekend.

Now...back to Bill Harris: He has 302 films in his alphabetical list, but only 295 titles in his rating list. I could go through and try to find the 7 missing ones (one of which I'm sure is in our top 30

) but there are a number of members who have this problem, and I'd rather they do the honors of synching their lists. However, since he's our official leader in the cause, I'll give him a break

The next update should reflect his total of 302.

Hope that clears up any confusion!