Neutral as of tonite. Opinions needed for 1st HDdvd viewing experience... - Page 2

Ivy Mike · 09-07-2007, 11:39 PM

Question for the neutral owners out there. How do you make a decision on all the Warners releases?

A curious inquiry from a poor decision maker...

I'm thinking I'll go neutral as well like Dave, but I'm sort of curious how you guys make decisions on the neutral releases (assuming all things equal when it comes to what's included on the disc).

Douglas Monce · 09-08-2007, 12:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ivy Mike

Question for the neutral owners out there. How do you make a decision on all the Warners releases?

A curious inquiry from a poor decision maker...

I'm thinking I'll go neutral as well like Dave, but I'm sort of curious how you guys make decisions on the neutral releases (assuming all things equal when it comes to what's included on the disc).

I started out with HD DVD so basically I'm buying blu-ray only if its not on HD DVD. If the blu-ray version had something interesting (special features or what not) that was NOT on the HD DVD then I would lean that direction.

Doug

TonyD · 09-08-2007, 12:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ivy Mike

Question for the neutral owners out there. How do you make a decision on all the Warners releases?

A curious inquiry from a poor decision maker...

I'm thinking I'll go neutral as well like Dave, but I'm sort of curious how you guys make decisions on the neutral releases (assuming all things equal when it comes to what's included on the disc).

i have an xa1 and a ps3.

i decide blu first because of the ease of use and quickness of the ps3 compared to xa1.

then i go to true hd for xa1 as i dont have pcm or uncompressed sound ability from ps3.

then i go features.

whichever has better features.

i'm considering 300, i'll pick hd dvd for that due to 1. true hd abiility and then pip bluescreen feature not on the blu version.

if all is equal i go blu.

Paul_Scott · 09-08-2007, 12:41 AM

Quote:

Question for the neutral owners out there. How do you make a decision on all the Warners releases? A curious inquiry from a poor decision maker...

I'm thinking I'll go neutral as well like Dave, but I'm sort of curious how you guys make decisions on the neutral releases (assuming all things equal when it comes to what's included on the disc).

I've taken a look at both formats and came to a conclusion that one had more advantages that would translate to long term viability.

On the other hand, I actually like the ergonomics and operational qualities of the other format better.

So basically I have to choose between one format that I honestly think will be around longer, vs one format that I enjoy playing the media on more.

But then here is something else to consider. Let's say I amass a sizable collection of software on one format. Then for one reason or another I end up bricking my player. Which player from which format would be more painless to replace so I could just go back to watching my content?

For these reasons, I lean towards one format more heavily, but I still buy some dual format titles on the other...just because I can.
And because I want to make sure there is an incentive to keep both players active and their purchase justified

Dave Mack · 09-08-2007, 01:46 AM

good question on the wb releases...

I do have to say that after 2 nites with both, the PS3 seems much faster, more responsive and less quirky than the hd-a2 as far as the mechanics go. PQ and AQ are stellar but when you're used to the PS3 and the truly instant response to say hitting the FF button, it's a bit weird even though the a2 seems like more of a dvd player and less of a "game" machine.
It took me hours to figure out the "can not find server" quirk was because it needed to reboot and rest while I was trying to upgrade the firmware. The PS3 connects to the net so effortlessly it's child's play. I finally burned an ISO image to a CDR and was still getting the error message when upgrading. I did a search for hd-a2 can not find server and found a review where the writer had the same issue and advised powering down for 10 minutes. It worked, firmware is upgraded but it just seems like the player itself will have quirks.

Good question though as far as which format.

DavidJ · 09-08-2007, 01:51 AM

The PS3 really is a great Blu-ray machine even if many find it unconventional. I try to base my decision on differences between releases...audio options, special features, etc. After that, it sometimes comes down to the best deal i can find. I also have more local friends who have HD DVD so I sometimes go red to loan to them. That is what made my Planet Earth decision.

troy evans · 09-08-2007, 04:09 AM

Everyone has made excellent recommendations. Here are three of my favorite HD DVD releases, "Last Samurai" awesome, "Matrix Trilogy" speaks for it's self, and finally "V for Vendetta" which has to be one of the most impressive HD DVD releases to date. It's hard to pick a bad one with what everyone here recommended.You may not like some of the films,but, you'll love how they look and sound.

Flemming.K · 09-08-2007, 10:18 AM

Grand Prix. In terms of visuals, the most impressive HD title released.

Jim_K · 09-08-2007, 11:07 AM

Quote:

Question for the neutral owners out there. How do you make a decision on all the Warners releases?

A curious inquiry from a poor decision maker...

I'm thinking I'll go neutral as well like Dave, but I'm sort of curious how you guys make decisions on the neutral releases (assuming all things equal when it comes to what's included on the disc).

Well ever since I went format free I've gone with the Blu-Ray version. The response time and speed of the PS3 over the XA2 is one reason. Also playback reliability on my PS3 has been flawless. I've had a handful of minor hiccups and burps with the XA2, which were a little annoying but forgivable - thankfully no grand mal seizures i.e. titles that refused to play.

Two things I prefer with the XA2 is the front panel readout (lacking on the PS3) and that I can keep my wood/glass cabinet closed when using the XA2, something I can't do when playing a Blu-Ray as I have to remember to keep the cabinet door open when using the PS3 because of the amount of heat it generates.

Also the combo vs. non-combo releases make my decisions more palatable.

Jim_K · 09-08-2007, 11:09 AM

Oh and the recommended HD DVD title for Dave............The Thing.