William,
The posts above are correct in that an S-VHS player would provide better VHS playback, especially since an S-VHS VCR would allow you to use an S-Video cable to feed your display for regular VHS tapes and S-VHS tapes.
I have an over-the-top S-VHS VCR setup with cabling as good as any used today in any home theater to make sure "just in case" that all components in my VCR system in no way contribute to degradation of playback, as I still watch VHS and Super VHS (I even have some Super VHS films) along with DVD and satellite. I ran split-screen A/B tests with my S-VHS VCR to select an S-Video cable for it and picked the same type cable after the testing for both standard definition satellite and the S-VHS VCR.
But all the above stuff is lunatic fringe stuff and not necessary for most. I wouldn't recommend spending over $25 for a VCR composite or S-Video cable unless you also have a professional-grade VCR and high-end display so all equipment compliments each other. Use what cabling came/comes with the VCR if possible to save $$.
