TiVo or ReplayTV

David Blair · 03-18-2004, 05:19 PM

I'm seriously thinking about getting either a 40 hour TiVo or ReplayTV. Is there a clear favorite between these? Can you use either of these without the one time charge or monthly fee(yeah, I'm cheap)?

Jeff Bamberger · 03-19-2004, 11:50 AM

David,

I have a TiVO and don't know how I lived without it. I cannot vouch for Replay, since I have never used one. So all I can say is that if you have TiVO you will be happy. For more information, take a peek at:

www.tivocommunity.com

Cameron Yee · 03-19-2004, 12:02 PM

I bought a refurbed Replay model that has the commercial advance. Great feature, especially with the annoying American Idol time filler. I've not used a Tivo so I can't say how the functionality compares. Initially I wasn't sure if I would get that much out of it, but being able to watch shows when I want is definitely a plus. I was a bit reluctant about the fee, but in comparison to doing a manual record for everything I want to see, it's definitely better to have the service.

John Giddens · 03-19-2004, 12:35 PM

I own 3 Replays and I love them. The newer Replays won't work past their trial period without a subscription or lifetime activation and to the best of my knowledge same thing goes with a Tivo. I don't think Tivo has a lifetime activation option. The Replays have a nifty ability to be networked to your computer right out of the box. Also through third party software you can dump shows to your computer to burn to DVD's and you can use some of your extra hard drive space on your computer to hold shows. The earlier 5000 series Replays have a commercial skip feature that allows you to skip through commercial segments with one button press. Be warned the newer 5500 series doesn't have this option. Unless you have Direct TV satellite the Replays have an advantage in my opinion. For more information than you ever wanted to know about Replays check out http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/forum...?s=&forumid=27 . It's my understanding you can get a 5040 for $119.99 direct from DNNA right now.

Jeff Bamberger · 03-19-2004, 02:37 PM

Standalone TiVOs do have a lifetime option for $299. New DirecTiVOs only have a monthly of $4.99, but if you subscribe to Total Choice Premier from DTV, they will waive the TiVO fee.

**HTF Ads**

David Blair · 03-19-2004, 05:18 PM

There are features on both that I like. With the Replay giving you the option of transferring to the computer, I may have to give it a try.

Thanks guys.

Adam Gregorich · 03-20-2004, 01:58 AM

Replay TV has a network jack so you can plug it into your cable/dsl line. With TIVO you have to get a USB network adapter. I know the Replay has composite, s-video and component (480p) outputs, I don't think the TIVO has 480P component outputs. You can use the TIVO to access pictures AND music off your PC (extra $99). The Replay will only access pictures (no extra cost). I have a Replay TV and I think it's great.

Richard Beckman · 03-22-2004, 08:36 PM

When you combine the capabilities of the networkable (wired or wireless) ReplayTV with Java-based DVArchive 3.0 (Mac, Windows, or Linux)you have a powerful combination to satisfy virtually any time-shifting and archiving need. check it out!

Cameron Yee · 03-22-2004, 08:44 PM

It wasn't until I saw this thread that I remembered the ethernet port on my Replay so I spent much of the weekend integrating it into my new network. I went with Replay because I was able to get it at a better price than Tivo at the time and I went with the general consensus about it having more features and tweakability. After trying three of the primary programs DVArchive wins hands down for features, though the others are good for basic functionality. I wish I'd done it all sooner, then I'd have Karen Sisco (and all the other good shows that seem to be getting the axe).

So, go with Replay.

Sue B · 03-25-2004, 08:31 PM

I have TIVO so I can't comment on Replay. TIVO allows you to get a season pass which will follow the show even if it changes nights/times. This is a great feature. I don't know if Replay does this or if the PVR's built into dish network or cable can do this.

Fast forwarding is fine. Just fast forward through the commericals and if you go too far, TIVO has this wonderful habit of backing it right up to the beginning of programming.

Also TIVO's artificial intelligence for suggestions & wishlists (allows you to search for movies/shows using a key word as well as actor/actress/director) is great. I tend to like history/documentaries and wishlists allow you to find all shows covering a topic in one fell swoop.

Good luck