Home Theater Forum - View Single Post

Matthew Brown · 04-18-2008, 09:10 AM

I've seen listings on Amazon for Collector's Editions of 3 Joy Division albums. I believe these may also have different material than what is in the box set, Heart and Soul.

I didn't get the box set because I have the original pressings of the CD's and maybe with the exception of one song, everything else.

Does anybody have the collector's editions? I am interested if the remastering makes them worth a purchase. I'm not interested if they are just "louder". These are double CD's but I don't know if the extras are previously unreleased.

With a movie coming out soon if not already, I would expect some more reissues soon so I will wait unless these are really worth getting. I'd love a version of "Ceremony" with the vocals up more during the first verse but I doubt that was ever recorded. I've heard New Order's version and while I love the music the vocal don't have the impact that the Joy Division version did.

04-18-2008, 09:10 AM	#1 of 3
Matthew Brown Member Join Date: Sep 1999 Local Time: 08:00 AM Local Date: 10-13-2008 Posts: 824	Joy Division Collector's Editions I've seen listings on Amazon for Collector's Editions of 3 Joy Division albums. I believe these may also have different material than what is in the box set, Heart and Soul. I didn't get the box set because I have the original pressings of the CD's and maybe with the exception of one song, everything else. Does anybody have the collector's editions? I am interested if the remastering makes them worth a purchase. I'm not interested if they are just "louder". These are double CD's but I don't know if the extras are previously unreleased. With a movie coming out soon if not already, I would expect some more reissues soon so I will wait unless these are really worth getting. I'd love a version of "Ceremony" with the vocals up more during the first verse but I doubt that was ever recorded. I've heard New Order's version and while I love the music the vocal don't have the impact that the Joy Division version did. Hong Kong DVD Reviews and News http://www.loveandbullets.com New Jersey Punk Rock http://www.NJPUNKONLINE.COM Last edited by Matthew Brown : 04-18-2008 at 10:49 AM.