Home Theater Forum - View Single Post - American Idol

Mike Williams · 03-12-2008, 03:23 PM

Ronald, from here on out, it's only one person per week, but I agree with you that it will be either Kristy Lee or David Hernandez. Both need to go quickly, along with Amanda.

Chikezie (I call him Chiclets, because he has such little teeth that remind me of Chiclets) surprised me as well, since I had him pegged to be the first of the Top 12 to go home.

I didn't believe David Archuletta would have a bad performance the entire competition. Forgetting the lyrics (3 times, no less) is nearly unforgiveable, but the song wouldn't have been much better if he hadn't. He's a ballad-kind-of-guy. If forgetting the lyrics is unforgiveable in Hollywood week and almost a certain axe, how much worse is it when you get to this stage, and certainly have more than a day to pick and learn your song?

I wasn't as crazy about Brooke last night as many others here. She was very breathy throughout, her voice completely cut out at the end of many of her notes, and she really didn't need the added pressure of the piano, which I think affected her song.

Carly -- I think she has a really good voice -- Sorry. Is it me, or does it seem like her Irish accent gets heavier each week?

David Hernandez -- puke

Amanda -- If they hadn't given the title of her song, I wouldn't have had any idea what she sang. I've been screaming for her to go home ever since she butchered that Kansas song, and I don't think she's done any song any favors since.

Ramiele -- I love her. She's so cute. I love her voice. She gets a pass in my book.

Kristy Lee -- I thought she had gone "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" on us, every bit as much as Chikezie did in his song. I love "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" but I don't love squaredancing. That was awful!

03-12-2008, 03:23 PM	#514 of 1270
Mike Williams Member Join Date: Mar 2003 Local Time: 05:34 PM Local Date: 10-15-2008 Posts: 925	Re: American Idol - Season 7 Ronald, from here on out, it's only one person per week, but I agree with you that it will be either Kristy Lee or David Hernandez. Both need to go quickly, along with Amanda. Chikezie (I call him Chiclets, because he has such little teeth that remind me of Chiclets) surprised me as well, since I had him pegged to be the first of the Top 12 to go home. I didn't believe David Archuletta would have a bad performance the entire competition. Forgetting the lyrics (3 times, no less) is nearly unforgiveable, but the song wouldn't have been much better if he hadn't. He's a ballad-kind-of-guy. If forgetting the lyrics is unforgiveable in Hollywood week and almost a certain axe, how much worse is it when you get to this stage, and certainly have more than a day to pick and learn your song? I wasn't as crazy about Brooke last night as many others here. She was very breathy throughout, her voice completely cut out at the end of many of her notes, and she really didn't need the added pressure of the piano, which I think affected her song. Carly -- I think she has a really good voice -- Sorry. Is it me, or does it seem like her Irish accent gets heavier each week? David Hernandez -- puke Amanda -- If they hadn't given the title of her song, I wouldn't have had any idea what she sang. I've been screaming for her to go home ever since she butchered that Kansas song, and I don't think she's done any song any favors since. Ramiele -- I love her. She's so cute. I love her voice. She gets a pass in my book. Kristy Lee -- I thought she had gone "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" on us, every bit as much as Chikezie did in his song. I love "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" but I don't love squaredancing. That was awful!