I thought Narnia was well-done, with it's heart in the right place. I found it a bit dull, but it's a competent film.
Sorry Josh...I only bring Pan's up when someone else does
For me, it's not quite as good as The Fountain, but it is MUCH more accessible. It just belongs in discussions with The Departed and United 93. Not Eragon.
Back to Eragon, Malcolm nails it. It was written by a 15 year old. I wrote stuff ripping off Aliens when I was 12. While it sucked, it was probably better than Alien Resurrection
Long story short, if you think it'll be good...maybe you'll enjoy it. I think it would be awful, so for me it probably would be.
I would like to hear more HTF reviews. I thank Simon for his...I am not surprised at his opinion.