Home Theater Forum - View Single Post

Tom Martin · 09-23-2004, 08:36 AM

when it comes to great trilogies, these guys are the owners! but it's pretty hard to pick a winner cuz of the different versions. we have the original Star Wars and the new enhanced Star Wars. we have the theater version od Lord of the Rings and the special extended versions, i know, Return of the King isn't out yet but i doubt it'll disappoint.

anyway, i personally happen to find LotR more interesting, cinematically beautiful, much less cheesy(corny lines), structured better, and more well organized.

i'll break it down like this.

SW original: 9
LotR theater: 9

SW SE 9.5
LotR EE: 10

09-23-2004, 08:36 AM	#1 of 96
Tom Martin Join Date: Nov 2003 Local Time: 07:49 PM Local Date: 12-05-2008 Posts: 151	Star Wars vs Lord of the Rings. when it comes to great trilogies, these guys are the owners! but it's pretty hard to pick a winner cuz of the different versions. we have the original Star Wars and the new enhanced Star Wars. we have the theater version od Lord of the Rings and the special extended versions, i know, Return of the King isn't out yet but i doubt it'll disappoint. anyway, i personally happen to find LotR more interesting, cinematically beautiful, much less cheesy(corny lines), structured better, and more well organized. i'll break it down like this. SW original: 9 LotR theater: 9 SW SE 9.5 LotR EE: 10