Posts by Jarod M

Feeling a little sensitive there, Bill?  I don't know why YOU are piping up about this.  I didn't name you, nor was I referring to you.  You're responding to an argument that I didn't...

Could this be a new transfer?  I have the 2000 DVD release.  Surely they aren't using going back that far.   There was another release a few years later, but I don't know if it looked any better than the 2000 release.

Quote: Originally Posted by JohnMor  Can we please tone down the arrogance?  The (unnecessary) definition you provided is completely superfluous to the discussion.  You still haven't said HOW...

Quote: Originally Posted by Craig S  So in other words, you're assuming everyone who has actually seen the discs (reviewers AND HTF members) and is reporting back that they are fine is a first-time viewer...

Quote: Originally Posted by JohnMor  ???  That doesn't even make sense.  If someone was happy with their original discs, they wouldn't have needed to purchase the newer.  Why do...

Quote: Originally Posted by dpippel    Yep, I'm just an ignorant tool without a clue as to what I'm looking at on this Blu-ray. In fact I must be either a sheeple or a Joe Sixpack, because I found...

Actually I was referring to the "biggest complainers."  And even though he gave it an overall positive rating (which he pretty much had to considering he gave the TE 3 out of 5), Kenneth Brown has definitely been one of the...

Quote: Originally Posted by JohnMor  It has zero to do with ignorance.  Either something pleases someone visually, or it does not.  And if their disc pleases them, that's what matters. ...

Quote: Originally Posted by Dave H  What's interesting is, on the other forums, I have only seen one poster say the disc looked awful while actually watching it on a 120" front projected screen (and this...

Peter Jackson DID weigh in personally.  It's right here.  Back then, they actually took green OUT of Hobbiton.   Quote: Originally Posted by Bill Hunt  Hey, it made me laugh. ;) The reality...