Home Theater Forum  ›  Forums  ›  Home Theater Hardware  ›  Display Devices (TVs/Projectors)  ›  Confirm or aleve my plasma fears

Confirm or aleve my plasma fears

#1
Rating: 0
After a faithful 7 years of service from my Panasonic PT-47WX49 HD RPTV, I'm finally ready to retire the old gal and upgrade to a new set.  Having recently moved into a new house with a finished basement perfectly suited for a home theater, I've turned my eye on the new Panasonic 58" V10 plasma.  I was paranoid about RPTV burn-in when I pulled the trigger 7 years ago, but I calibrated with Avia and never had any problems.  I played plenty of video games and watched a ton of 4:3 content as well as plenty of sports with static overlays.  I'm sure this is just a result of having contrast set to its proper levels (if not a little lower) and the only real reason I'm upgrading is the lack of HDMI/1080p/720p support.  The set still looks great.

As you can imagine, now that I'm considering a move to plasma, my paranoia has returned.  I know that great strides have been made in Plasma technology in the last few years, but I see some people still claiming that burn-in is still real and common and that you have to be a "responsible watcher".  Is that really the case?  With proper calibration and not doing anything stupid (like leaving it on and paused overnight) how susceptible to burn-in am I going to be?  I never want to be in the situation where I have to say "I would love to watch this movie marathon, but it's 8 hours of 2:35:1 and I shouldn't risk it".  After all, tv is for enjoyment and if I have to make decisions like that, it detracts from that enjoyment.

If its really a problem, then I supposed I'd go LED, but everything I read still says plasma is quality king.

1. Light controlled environment
2. 33/33/33 Movies, Gaming, TV
3. Picture quality is my most important feature in a TV

Thoughts?
Export to Wiki
#2
Rating: 0
Burn in won't be a problem for you. You do have to worry about image retention, however this is also a problem with LCDs. Keeping your brightness lower than normal and avoiding persistent images during your first 100 hours of use will "break it in" and you should be fine.

1. That's good because plasmas have comparatively low light output.
2. 1% porn?
3. Enjoy your vastly superior image to LCD screens.

"Because he's the hero that Gotham deserves, but not the one it needs right now... and so we'll hunt him... because he can take it... because he's not a hero... he's a silent guardian, a watchful protector... a DARK KNIGHT."

Export to Wiki
#3
Rating: 0
I've heard also that with modern plasmas, if you set the peak white-level to something... reasonable, than you can do just about anything without any significant risk.  (Enough qualifiers there?)  Reasonable white-level was given to me as a defined brightness -- some number of Nits (more commonly used with measuring light output of LCD screens.)  Unfortunately, I can't remember what that number actually was, but I think it was (but don't quote me on this,) in excess of 170 Nits.  My desk-top LCD is set and calibrated to approx 140 Nits, and I can't imagine watching that in a dark room!

(Of course I'm used to projectors, so I watch in the dark.)

Leo
Export to Wiki
#4
Rating: 0
Thanks guys, that makes me feel a lot better.  Now all I need is to decide if the 58" model is big enough or if the 65" is worth the extra dough.  I'm probably dreaming on that one and will most likely end up with the cheaper 58.
Export to Wiki
#5
Rating: 0
Good luck with your purchase.  I just ordered a Panny 50" S1 Plasma.  Both Best Buys near me were out of stock (Scranton/Wilkes-Barre) so I'll be picking it up the weekend after Thanksgiving.  I'm excited!!

I was torn initially, because I might do some gaming on the screen and thought I might lean toward LCD.  I also like the physical design of the Samsungs (I think less is more and they're beautiful.. the 550 plasma from Samsung).  But I was waltzing through Sears and they played clips from the newest Ice Age movie and OMG was it beautiful.  I again realized why I have to focus on straight PQ over other issues.  I couldn't compromise my PQ for a nice looking bezel or what might be turning into the urban legend of Panasonic burn in, so the Panasonic Plasma it was for me!


Mr. JBL has made my first home theater possible.

Export to Wiki
#6
Rating: 0
Adam, I'm not that far from you (live in Plymouth Meeting, work in Exton).  It looks like the V10s are all out of stock in my neck of the woods.  Though with all the talk of 3D tvs launching in 2010, part of my wants to wait it out.  I've promised myself to wait at least until Christmas/SuperBowl sales.  Good luck with your S1.
Export to Wiki