Re: Tosh posts 4.0 Software for HD-DVD Players....
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Stephen_J_H
Installed this update on my A30 last night and watched The Thing. It froze up twice, but when I chapter skipped back and hit play, it played through just fine both times. Anyone else run into any problems?
|
I don't think that your playback issues are
Thing-specific or related to the firmware upgrade. Although I sold it before watching the entire film after learning of the imminent BD, I didn't have any issues with the HD DVD when spot viewing it. However, I have had those kinds of freeze ups on other HD DVDs (most often rentals with scratches but sometimes with even clean discs).
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by DaveM4964
It's a Magnavox 51 inch set. I've had it a little more than 3 years. It has no HDMI input so i'm using component.
I talked to someone at Toshiba last night. Basically i was told that 4:3 dvds are not compatible with hd-dvd players and nothing can be done about the stretching problem.
|
Dave, I'm not laughing at you but that last sentence is hilarious. In my experience and based on my understanding, this rep is just wrong. My HD-D1 (the Costco/WalMart model equivalent of the HD-A1) stretched 4:3 content to 16x9 also. It is a design flaw of the player. Many first gen machines did it, and obviously from your experience some second gen also. My XA2 does NOT. The problem is not HD DVD-specific as my first gen Panasonic DMP-BD10 does it, too.
I think the reason your format button doesn't work when you're playing the A2 is because your Magnavox, not unlike my early Tosh HDTV, locks you out of aspect ratio control whenever it is displaying anything of greater resolution than 480p.
If indeed you've lowered the A2's output resolution to 480 and you still don't have access to the TV's aspect ratio control, then it would seem that the content being flagged 4:3 even trumps the resolution issue and indeed there's nothing you can do. But it's not because there's something fundamentally incompatible about 4:3 DVDs and HD DVD players. I think this problem was fixed with third gen HD DVD machines.