Re: Warner Bros. upsets me
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ethan Riley
What I am saying is that I don't think BluRay is going to exist simply as a superior alternative to SD; I think it's going to take over completely.
|
I'm not so sure you're right. One reason is simple: VHS players couldn't play DVDs, but Blu-Ray players can play DVDs. So they can co-exist quite cozily for a long time.
But I'm also not certain that Blu-Ray will triumph. Mind you, I recently got a Blu-Ray player, and I love it, much more than I'd expected to. I've fallen into that trap that I now find DVD resolution insufficient!
That said, for a new format to take over, it must offer a tremendous advantage over the existing format. CDs were much better than LPs (despite the complaints of some audiophiles) -- they were more portable, didn't scratch, could access specific songs at the touch of a button, etc. iPods (and the like) offered even greater portability, the capacity to amass your entire music collection in one tiny device, new music could be bought without having to go to a store, and (I regret to say) they were an ideal format for music pirated over the internet.
Similarly, DVDs were very obviously better than VHS -- they looked better even on an average television, they took up less room, you never had to be kind and rewind them, and as with CDs, you could access any part at any time.
Now you don't have to sell me on Blu-Ray, because I'm sold. But you have to have an expensive television (and, for the audio, stereo system) to see and hear the difference between Blu-Ray and standard DVD. The other bells and whistles are really just fancier versions of what's already available on DVD, and those bells and whistles are not what sold DVD en masse, anyway. The failure of the higher resolution audio formats (SACD and DVD-Audio) shows that improved quality is not necessarily the key if everybody's happy enough with the quality we already have. Many of my friends buy DVDs mostly to play for their kids in the mini-van. (Not I! I watch on my big screen, and my kids complain about the lack of DVD in the car!) So 1080p doesn't really mean anything to them.
I hope you're right, because I love my Blu-Ray. But I have my doubts.