Re: Sound proof curtains.
Ok, kiddies, gather round. Here's the absolute skinny on "black out" curtains. (Apologies for "hijacking" this thread, I think.)
Note 1: I needed black-colored blackout curtains for my theater room. I did not choose to use "blinds," or "roman shades," or any "layering" of multiple drapes using "blackout liners," like Roc-Lon Liners (which do work). These are other options, probably worth exploring. But I needed one certain thing (black blackout curtains) to match the room and block the light.
Note 2: Going shopping for blackout shades? Bring along your police-issue 3-cell MagLight. The bottom line is that if light from the MagLight gets thru the curtains (when you put the MagLight behind the curtains hanging in the store) then light from your windows will also.
Note 3: I am a very angry man.
There are basically three companies making "black out shades." The first is Roc-Lon, which makes commercial window treatments and consumer-level blackout liners, which are used in conjunction with an "over drape." You can use a white Roc-Lon liner, which costs about $25 per panel, behind any color drape or curtain. I will be ignoring this option for the purpose of this email, as noted above. The second company is Ellery Homestyles, based in NY. At the moment, I hate this company. But let me say that they have multiple brands and types of "black out" curtains under the brand name "Eclipse," available in most consumer homeware stores. We'll get back to Ellery in a moment. The third company is Springs, based in NC, which makes "Solaris" brand "black out" curtains, available in Linens-N-Things. There are other store-brands, such as Linden at JCPenney.
First, you need to know that no fabric-based "black out" curtain works, at all. Solaris Portland doesn't work. Eclipse anything doesn't work. (And Penney's Linden brand fabric based curtains also do not work.) Put your MagLight behind them (when you're shopping in the store) and you'll plainly see: even tho they all scream "Blocks 99% of light! Black out light for a good night's sleep even during the day!" ... they are all lying.
Each of these two main curtain brands (and some store brands) does make a "faux suede" curtain in limited colors. These curtains are very thick and heavy, almost like "microfiber," and do block a certain amount of light successfully. Use your MagLight if you are considering these materials. I did not want these kinds of curtains because they were not available in the color I needed.
Why I am so angry at the moment. Two months ago I bought Ellery's Eclipse Amanda curtain at my local BedBathBeyond. Package copy says boldly: "Blocks all unwanted light... Sleep in complete darkness any time of day... Blocks out over 99% of light... In laboratory testing, the Eclipse curtain blocked an average of 99.8% of light." (Seriously.) Yet, the curtain was basically sheer. Didn't block any light. I took pictures, wrote to the company. They were nice enough to say maybe something was wrong with the ones I bought, and they sent me a whole new set! But, the set they sent as a replacement was the same exact product, which did not block any light at all. I took more pictures, I wrote back to the company, and... they stopped helping me. Finally, I got a nice customer service woman on the phone at the company's NC shipping facility who told me, lo and behold, Ellery also makes MORE TYPES of black out curtains, with cool names like ThermaWeave and ThermaBack, and they are available under these names in other stores! They even have a complete separate website for these brandier brands! (So, um, why didn't the head office in NY tell me this?)
So, in spite, here's a rundown of Ellery's "Eclipse" black out curtain brands and their effectiveness, or lack thereof:
- Eclipse, available at BedBathBeyond for $40 per panel. Useless, practically sheer. Take them back.
- ThermaBack/ThermaWeave, available at WalMart, KMart, Sears. More interesting than the plain fabric curtains available under the basic "Eclipse" name, but just as useless, and all practically sheer. Avoid them.
- ThermaLiner, also at Wal-K-SearsMart, is, in fairness, a Roc-Lon-type vinyl liner; it does block the light, as its package claims. But it's a white vinyl liner, needs a curtain over it.
- Eclipse Triple Weave, also at Wal-K-SearsMart, sheer according to the MagLight test.
So, what can you buy to block the light? Unfortunately, the only true non-layered, non-suede light-blocking blackout curtain available in fashion colors (like the "black" I needed) is an Ellery brand of Eclipse curtain only available at... JCPenney. It's called the Robert Eclipse, and the only reason I know about it is because a nice woman at Ellery's shipping facility mentioned it; the guys at Ellery HQ in NY obviously do not want to sell much stuff. I mean, why have multiple types of curtains that all claim to "block 99% of light," when none of them do except ONE?
I went to JCPenney, and put the MagLight on it, and the Robert Eclipse curtain in black BLOCKED THE FRIGGING LIGHT COMPLETELY. I brought it home, hung it next to the Eclipse Amanda, took a picture of it blocking the light (next to the light streaming in from the "Eclipse" Amanda), and I am about to send an angry email to the guys at Ellery that asks, among other things, "Why did't you tell me about the product -- YOUR PRODUCT -- that actually works... months ago in the first place?"
If I knew how to post images to this thread, I'd lay it out for you. Only the Robert Eclipse, by (yech!) Ellery Homestyles, available at JCPenney, actually blocks the light like a real black out curtain!
So there. Months of heartache and hard work condensed into a little thread posting.
[Micah collapses on floor, but at least his theater is dark and quiet now.]
MC