Red Eye is not that big a film though. It's the thriller de jour. It's Phonebooth or Cellular or The Forgotten, meaning that without a star in it the film will quickly be forgotten and Murphy will remain more famous for his Batman Role than Red Eye (IMO of course).
Bale was not a major star and his role is huge. Wilkinson is also not a "name" star. He's had success with awards, critical respect, but you don't lead a film with him to draw box office. You don't say Tom Wilkinson is in it and get people at the water cooler saying "oh yeah".
Oldman you can, though still he is more famous as being a great actor than as a movie star. Wannatabe is not a star and had zero recognition prior to Last Samurai, and still remains a "who" type of actor.
BB had tons of acting TALENT in it, but Katie Holmes might have been the 2nd or 3rd most famous STAR in the film. Go to the mall and poll people, ask them to talk about each of these actors, their roles, how they have heard of them, whatever.
Tell me that "Katie Holmes is dating Tom Cruise" won't be perhaps leading the list, with Michael Caine ahead of her in general recognition. Liam Neeson is in the ballpark of as well of course, thanks to high profile roles in films like Gangs of New York, Star Wars and Schindler's List among others.
More people know that Winona Ryder and Reeves were in Dracula than know that Oldman was the star namesake of the film.
So with that in mind I agree with you Adam when you say
Quote:
| It's getting an actor able to become the Joker, not an actor whose persona is so large that the Joker must become him. |