Netflix Rental Disc On-going Thread

#1

Rating: 0

7/23/04 at 10:19pm

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

This is disappointing. Neflix sent a "rental" disc for THE BUTTERFLY EFFECT which does not include everything that a purchaser of the set will get. Now, the same thing happens for STARSKY & HUTCH (2004). It's a rental disc but I don't know if I'm missing anything (I'll check later). Are there any other titles like this? I wrote to Netflix expressing my dismay at this practice.

#2

Rating: 0

7/24/04 at 6:10am

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

There are other titles. I know that Gus Van Sant's Elephant was a rental only disc and did not include the special features included in the retail version.

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#3

Rating: 0

7/24/04 at 6:22am

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

hmmmm... after reading this post, and some complaints in the Butterfly Effect review thread, I decided to check out the Netflix description (it's in my queue). Check this out!
I am not sure when this changed, but it looks like they are covering their asses now.

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#4

Rating: 0

7/24/04 at 7:01pm

danak
offline

Joined: September 2002
Post Count: 334

I've seen Usenet posters give the opinion that Netflix does this because those discs are double sided and more prone to damage, and that NF allegedly asks for special rental versions that are not double sided (which means more discs sometimes). That may explain why for some TV series that they offer, there are more discs listed on the NF website than on Amazon (Example: 5 from NF vs 3 from Amazon for Wonder Woman).

Dana

#5

Rating: 0

7/24/04 at 8:28pm

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

That's correct...there was a discussion of this before, but I don't remember which thread. I don't have a problem with it if they advertise it as such (i.e. Butterfly Effect). However, the DISCS themselves still tell you to "flip the disc" to see the other cut or special features, and THAT bugs me!

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#6

Rating: 0

7/24/04 at 8:32pm

KarenDB
offline

Joined: May 2002
Post Count: 9

I just had Deliverance from Netflix. It was a two sided disk. One side for the widescreen and one for the mutilated version.

#7

Rating: 0

7/25/04 at 3:59pm

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

Fortunately, Starsky & Hutch (2004) had everything intact, but there are not many extra features on the original disc anyway so they don't lose anything.

Another Netflix "rental" title is The Big Bounce (2004).

Both of these titles are from Warner Bros. Is New Line Home Video still part of Warner? (Sneaky how Netflix put that disclaimer for The Butterfly Effect. Before that notice came up, I had written them a scathing, but professional, note about how disappointing TBE disc was.)

And they raise their prices for this?

#8

Rating: 0

7/26/04 at 10:16am

Jeff Gross
offline

Joined: February 2002
Post Count: 250

Quote:

Netflix does this because those discs are double sided and more prone to damage

I've been watching West Wing on DVD through NetFlix. The first season is 3 double sided discs. I received one of them that was cracked in the mail.

Although the second season is 3 double sided discs if you purchase it, NetFlix has it as 6 single sided discs.

#9

Rating: 0

7/26/04 at 5:43pm

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

Although the second season is 3 double sided discs if you purchase it, NetFlix has it as 6 single sided discs.

Before I address that quote, let me digress: I was a VERY early user of Netflix (I believe they only had 2 distribution centers at that time!). In the "old days", if there was a title that was a 2-disc release, you got both discs at once; please remember, 2-disc sets were the exception, not the rule at the time. Multi-disc sets were practically non-existent at that time. I think they changed the multi-disc DVD policy when The Sopranos came out. Here were people getting four discs at a time, even though their subscription was for three discs.

Now, regarding your statement: the answer is probably three-fold.
1. It (in theory) lets six different people rent from one set.
2. It makes more sense (and money) for Netflix since it forces you to rent six discs instead of three.
3. If one disc breaks, it still allows for five other rentals to occur until the disc is replaced.

And there you have it!

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#10

Rating: 0

7/27/04 at 2:53am

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

This is an assumption and Netflix is usually good about updating their pages, but this stands out negatively in my mind.

Hellboy is a 2-disc Special Edition being released today. However, when you rent the disc, it does not allow you to rent the "Bonus Disc" (as older multiple disc titles say). So I am assuming that this title will be yet another "rental" disc. But looking at the back cover, it seems as if the extras are split equally on both discs. Disc Two has some very interesting features (including "And Much More") that I would like to see. If anyone rents it soon, let us know here.

Maybe we should start compiling a list of these "rental" discs that Netflix is using just to see...

#11

Rating: 0

7/27/04 at 5:53am

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

If anyone rents it soon, let us know here.

My copy should be here tomorrow; I will post what I received Wed. afternoon.

I wish they would include a disclaimer in the film description along these lines: "This is a rental only disc and my not contain all the features of the commercial release."

How does Blockbuster, Hollywood Video, Walmart.com or Nicheflix handle the 2-disc issue? Anyone care to chime in?

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#12

Rating: 0

7/27/04 at 2:39pm

danak
offline

Joined: September 2002
Post Count: 334

Keith,

Quote:

Hellboy is a 2-disc Special Edition being released today. However, when you rent the disc, it does not allow you to rent the "Bonus Disc" (as older multiple disc titles say).

I had no problem clicking Rent on the Bonus Disc and putting it in my queue. It's winding its way to my mailbox as we speak (Wed or Thurs). You just have to search for Hellboy and both the movie disc and the bonus disc come up.

If you are thinking that it's supposed to be grouped together like many of the multi-disc documentary titles or TV series, Netflix doesn't usually do that with movie titles that have bonus discs; they are listed separately, except when the movie spans 2 discs (like Gangs of New York).

Dana

#13

Rating: 0

7/27/04 at 3:51pm

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

I think since I had Hellboy in my queue long before it was announced (I put it in my queue when the movie came out in theaters), Netflix just put the first disc in my queue. OKAY, Netflix, I was wrong on this one!

However, it would be a nice touch if they were to send an email asking if I would like to rent the Bonus Disc. They could put that in the email that says, "HELLBOY has been shipped."

Anyway, if anyone else sees "rental" discs like The Butterfly Effect, please let us know. Thanks!

I guess Starsky & Hutch and The Big Bounce don't count since they aren't missing any features.

#14

Rating: 0

7/27/04 at 10:34pm

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

I actually received Hellboy today (Tues.)!!! Good work Netflix! The FIRST TIME EVER that I got a title on its street date! All the features are the same as the copies I saw in stores today...can't wait to watch it after work on Wed.!

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#15

Rating: 0

7/29/04 at 10:33am

Thane
offline

Joined: June 1999
Post Count: 113

Another "rental disc" (also Warner) is the complete season 1 of the Waltons. Instead of 5 discs, there are 9 (!) through Netflix.

#16

Rating: 0

7/29/04 at 2:47pm

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

Keith:

Maybe you can ask one of the mods to change the title of this thread to Netflix Rental Disc Ongoing thread. I would be more than happy to add info to it!

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#17

Rating: 0

7/29/04 at 4:34pm

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

Sure, no problem!

Mods: Can you change the thread title as described above?

Thank you!

#18

Rating: 0

7/30/04 at 9:10am

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

Here's another one for the list, though it's not released yet...The Munsters Season One will be spread across six discs thru Netflix, but only three discs if you buy it.

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#19

Rating: 0

8/12/04 at 8:26pm

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

Here's another one from Warner:

Without a Trace: Season One

It's 8 discs at Netflix vs. 4 discs regular purchase.

Should this thread be moved out of Vendors Feedback? If so, which forum would it go in? It's not necessarily Film & Documentary nor is it TV on DVD. We are currently just keeping track of "rental" discs from Netflix. We're not giving feedback to Netflix anymore, are we?

#20

Rating: 0

8/14/04 at 4:29am

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

Here's another one, from HBO/Warner:

Six Feet Under: Season Two

As long as these rental discs do not sacrifice any content - like 6FU:S2 - then I'm okay with it. The The Butterfly Effect rental disc is not acceptable.

#21

Rating: 0

8/15/04 at 12:06pm

EricSchulz
offline

Joined: January 2004
Post Count: 2,536

Well, Warner is definitely a big player in this: both Dead Ringer and Lost Boys SE are rental version discs, but neither is missing any material that the retail versions have.

One of my favorite albums...

ABBA: "The Visitors"

#22

Rating: 0

8/22/04 at 3:50pm

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

Yes, Warner seems to be the only studio (New Line is a branch of Warner, right?) offering Netflix these "rental" discs. Here's another one:

Justice League: Starcrossed

I'll end it here since it's most likely Warner discs will fall into this category...

#23

Rating: 0

10/1/04 at 3:36am

danak
offline

Joined: September 2002
Post Count: 334

North and South: The Complete Collection is another special rental case. Amazon.com lists it with 5 discs and Netflix shows 8

Dana

#24

Rating: 0

10/8/04 at 9:01am

Chris Lockwood
offline

Joined: April 1999
Post Count: 2,951

> 2. It makes more sense (and money) for Netflix since it forces you to rent six discs instead of three.

Howso? They don't charge by the disc. If they sent a disk with more content, the average customer would keep it longer, meaning he'd go thru FEWER disks for his fixed monthly fee. So your point seems backward.

I got Starsky & Hutch from them, & it had a bunch of extras on it. I haven't compared it to what's in stores, but I doubt it was different.

When I search on a title, if there's a separate bonus disk, the search returns that as well. Also, the details for disk one usually mention there's a bonus disk.

> In the "old days", if there was a title that was a 2-disc release, you got both discs at once

When did those days end? I got the original Around the World in 80 Days from them way back in June 2004, a 2-disc set, & they mailed the disks separately but treated it as one title. I actually had 5 disks out at once.

Maybe when the movie itself occupies 2 disks, which is rare, they send them both, but for bonuses they don't. That makes sense, because some people don't care about the bonuses, so that 2nd disk may not get used. Even I, lover of extras, don't always put the 2nd disk in my queue.

Anyway, I can't complain about them treating 2 disks as 2 disks, when my plan is based on number of disks I can have out.

#25

Rating: 0

10/24/04 at 1:09pm

danak
offline

Joined: September 2002
Post Count: 334

The three That's Entertainment titles (That's Entertainment, That's Entertainment 2, and That's Entertainment 3) are one disc each retail but 2 discs from Netflix (and they aren't renting the bonus disc). The description of the discs say the first disc is the first half of the program and the second disc is the second half of the program, but I suspect one disc is the widescreen side of the disc and the second disc is the full screen side.

Dana in MD

#26

Rating: 0

1/4/05 at 8:28pm

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

Just got HBO's Carnivale and on Disc 1 there are only two episodes and it states: "Rental Disc - Not for Resale."

#27

Rating: 0

3/13/05 at 4:10am

Keith I
offline

Joined: May 2004
Location: Five-Oh!
Post Count: 927

It seems as if Netflix has extended their rental offer to Fox Home Video. The Pretender: Season 1 is spread over seven discs as compared to the four consumers get.

I think this is also Fox's first double-sided disc for a TV series. The Lone Gunmen is next, but it seems as if Netflix is renting these discs as double-sided (i.e., 3 discs total).
-

#28

Rating: 0

1/23/07 at 8:59pm

Cameron Yee
online

Joined: May 2002
Post Count: 6,896

Re: Netflix Rental Disc On-going Thread

I encountered my first rental disc from "Red Envelope Entertainment: A Netflix Company" for "Sherrybaby."

He was one of those people who would be neither a follower nor a leader, but only an aspiring heart, impatient in the failing body which imprisoned it. -- T. H. White, "The Once and Future King"

#29

Rating: 0

8/15/08 at 3:20pm

David Deeb
David Deeb
offline

Joined: November 2005
Location: Nashville, Tennessee
Post Count: 553

Re: Netflix Rental Disc On-going Thread

I know, I know... I resurrected an ancient thread, but hey, why start another one.

Anyone know if this practice still goes on, or does Netflix (and Blockbuster) just rent the full version now?

Tags

Other Threads

Recent Reviews

What Users Want

Re: Netflix Rental Disc On-going Thread

Re: Netflix Rental Disc On-going Thread

Got Facebook?

Already a User?

Create a New Account

Recent Discussions

Recent Reviews

Recent Wikis