Zenith 318 upconversion test/review
Television used in the test are: a Hitachi 65xwx20b CRT RPTV and a Memorex MT3010 HDTV LCD 30 inch panel. The Hitachi automatically upconverts all inputs to either 540p or 1080i. As such, I doubt if the Zenith’s upconversion would have any positive effect on the Hitachi monitor. It would be interesting to compare the component vs dvi inputs of the Hitachi. The Memorex is a different story. The Memorex does not have DVI inputs so an upconverting DVD player via components is a big plus. With a native resolution of 720p, I have high expectations on the Zenith’s upconversion abilities.
With the Hitachi, picture quality would be compared to the Philips 962sa that is currently connected via components. The Philips is a top rated dvd/sacd player that also sports the DCDI processing. With the Memorex, picture quality would be compared to the JVC former flagship, the JVC XV-D723GD which is currently connected to the Memorex via components; another top rated dvd/dvd-a player. Without a doubt, the Zenith would have its work cut out.
Initial impressions on the Zenith; the word cheesy comes to mind, especially for a $249 DVD. The build quality is more in line to the sub $100 market. Open the cover and it does not get any better. One of the flimsiest looking transport I have ever seen. Children should not be allowed to touch this fragile looking piece.The rest of the interior pretty much screams budget. On the other hand, the remote is pretty nice. Buttons are laid out nice and spaced adequately apart. The jog shuttle dial for forward and reverse is convenient..
I used chapters two and three on “The Pirates of the Caribbean” dvd. On chapter two, I paid special attention to details on the boat, color saturation with the different light conditions, details and depth from the hanging pirates , and the warning sign. On chapter three, I paid special attention to both actors complexion. The dvd is ruthluess in highlighting the acne problems of both actors. Look at Depp’s bandana , his skin showing through his wet shirt, and the water beading on his face. Look at her makeup, her eyebrowl, the details in her blouse, or her acne---can you count them?
On the Hitachi, as expected, switching between 480p, 720p, and1080i did nothing. The Hitachi did its own upconversion process. Through the components, the picture quality is very good. Good detail, good color saturation, good depth to the picture. I did not see any extraneous artifacts. Video quality is very very good. Through the DVI the picture was also very good. I had to adjust the video as the DVI had much higher brightness, contrast and color than the components. Again, switching between 480p,720p and 1080i showed no difference in video quality. The DVI was very sharp and detailed; but I preferred the component’s better depth and 3-D look. The component had a more natural film look to it than the DVI. The DVI connection was very buggy. Most of the time I could not get a signal down to the Hitachi. Had to either reboot the player or shut it down for a while. Seems like the Zenith’s DVI does not like to be powered down and fired up over and over. Compared to the Philips, the Zenith is not quite up to par. Bear in mind that the Philips is one of the better dvd players out there and the Zenith comes fairly close…picture quality was more close than they were apart. For the Hitachi, the Zenith is not worth the extra dollars for the upconverting feature. It would be more wise to purchase a straight-up $249 dvd player that would trade better build quality for the upconverting feature.
On the Memorex, the 480p picture quality was excellent. Great detail, sharpness, color saturation, and depth.. The 720p was also excellent, offering just a shade more detail than the 480p. The 1080i picture was notably worse than the 480p, blurring the fine details the 480p produced. At 1080i, I noticed a strange artifact where the black top and bottom bands are; a white hyphen like artifact. Sure enough, the 720p from the Zenith matched the Memorex native resolution perfectly; extrapolating the last ounce of information. Here the upconverting feature worked with the Memorex. We are not talking about night and day difference; it was subtle…perhaps on a larger screen the difference would have been more pronounced. LCD panels excel in detail and resolution and the Zenith brought out the best of the LCD. At times, the picture quality was so good it looked as if I was watching the action from the other side of the window. Compared to the $900 JVC, the Zenith put up a good fight. The JVC had a more natural, film like presentation, but the Zenith would be welcomed addition.
The Zenith produces a fine video picture, better than any budget dvd player ought to. Ultimately the upconversion feature was a non-factor with the Hitachi and with the Memorex only subtly. On larger non-upconverting montors, the Zenith upconversion may have been more noticeable. Yes, both the Philips and JVC produced a finer picture (even at only 480P)and it should at 2-3times the cost of the Zenith. I will reserve only a passing comment with regards to cd audio on the Zenith….don’t get rid of your cd player.