Dave Poehlman
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2000
- Messages
- 3,813
I've always wondered: Is "White trash" considered a racist term?I always thought it refered more to the lifestyle. Not that I'm some expert of poverty but when I think of trailer parks (and when you see their residents on Jerry Sringer) and other things associated with the term 'white trash' I don't usually see ethnic minorities in my mental picture. Maybe there are trailer parks full of minorities out there but when a tornado rips up trailer park apart the displaced residents on my tv are all white.
jeremy
The new rule seems to be: it's okay to make fun of members of the American "founder groups": WASPs (what used to be called "old Americans"), Germans, Dutch, Scandinavians, and the like (but not any of the Catholic ethnic groups, for example). And that's because these remain, despite all denials, the prestige groups in the society. Say what you will about any of those groups and it really doesn't matter, since, according to the underlying social ethos, there's really nothing inherently bad about being one of "them".[I said:trailer trash[/I]]Quote:
Germans, Dutch, Scandinavians, and the like (but not any of the Catholic ethnic groups, for example). And that's because these remain, despite all denials, the prestige groups in the society. Say what you will about any of those groups and it really doesn't matter, since, according to the underlying social ethos, there's really nothing inherently bad about being one of "them".Ask my father that question circa 1958 what it was like to be a German in post-war Canada.
Smartasses respond by saying Canadian and although this is true of all of us its never quite what the person meant when asking.I respond with "Canadian" when I'm asked my nationality. Being asked my ethnicity yields a different answer since it's a different question.
-JNS
If you are speaking of anti-German sentiment in the society following the wars, we had that in the U.S. as well during and after WW I. Street names were changed, businesses and homes were vandalized, people hid their ethnic identities wherever they could, etc.
That still does not address "inherent" worth. Being German or of German descent was considered bad for the moment because of the real and/or imagined harm that Germans had done or would do ("Germans are warmongerers; Germans are spies; Germans are saboteurs; Germans are brutes" etc.). That hasn't lasted, has it? And, if not, why not?
It's because the hostility was situational or "circumstantial", not because the society considered Germans or those of German descent inherently "inferior" or "other". If it had, the great German immigration waves of the nineteenth century would not have occurred here.
So, it's acts (real or imagined), not "essence" that lay behind the hostility you allude to. That's not being "inherently bad", but "pragmatically bad", at least in the popular imagination.
I hate PC and wish it had never been invented. Someone will ALWAYS be offended by something someone else says or does. So what. Get tougher skin.Cheers to that. PC = Wussification of society through euphemisms. Hmmm, wonder where Bill Maher is these days?
-JNS