Toshiba 57HDX82 vs. Pioneer SD-533HD5 (1 Viewer)

[Brent_N]

I posted this on a Home Theater Spot forum, but haven't received a lot of feedback. Hope you don't mind me posting here as well. Thanks.
___________________________
The 4:3 stretch modes are the main reason I am down to these two RPTVs - I have looked at each model's progressive stretch mode and they both look pretty good. The following are the pros and cons I am weighing.
Your input is appreciated.
Toshiba 57HDX82
Pros:

• Screen size
• Accepts 720p
• DVI input
• Works well in built-in installation (the grill comes off and there is a nice exposed bezel for custom installation)

:frowning: Cons:

• More $$ than Pioneer
• Reported ghosting and speaker hiss
• 480p upconversion

Pioneer SD-533HD5
Pros:

• Great price ($2300 locally)
• No upconversion of 480p

:frowning: Cons:

• Smaller size (may be too small at ~11-13 ft)
• Does not accept 720p
• No DVI input
• Doesn't work as well as Toshiba in built-in installation

 

[Juan_R]

My choice would be the Toshiba. I doubt you would be able to notice the upconversion. You would also be ready for the future with the DVI connection.