Sony NS9100ES vs. Pioneer Elite DV-79AVi (1 Viewer)

[Paul D. K.]

I'm looking to upgrade to an upconverting DVD/CD player that does a great job at both video and audio for use with my new Pioneer Pro1540 HD Plasma TV. I'm considering either a Sony DVPNS9100ES or Pioneer Elite DV-79AVi. Any feedback on either one of these units or, if at all possible, a head to head comparison would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks for the help.

 

[Dave H]

Not sure this will help, but I used to have the Sony 9100ES - never used the Pioneer. The picture quality for the Sony is pretty good, though not in the class of the recent Silicon Optix based players. The Sony has a slightly softer image, but very good color rendition. From a deinterlacing standpoint, the Sony H75 rates better on the benchmark tests. I never used it for audio, but have heard from many sources that it's outstanding.

 

[Paul D. K.]

Dave -

Thanks for the first hand insite to at least one of the models I'm considering. My local dealer isn't carrying either one in lieu of Blue-Ray and HD-DVD.

I'm assuming Silicon Optix is a "chip set" is that correct? If so, who uses it? Where can I find the benchmark tests you refer to so that I can see how each of the current (and possibly future models) I'm condering rates?

Thanks,

 

[Vegas 1]

Paul I've been using the Elite 79avi now for about a year and it has played flawlessly, video and audio are very good. Check out AVS forum for more reviews on both players.
Regards

 

[Kevin C Brown]

More here on both:

http://www.hometheaterhifi.com/cgi-b...deInt=0&mpeg=0

Bottom line, I think you can find betters players now for cheaper.

 

[Paul D. K.]

Kevin -

Thank you for the link. Very comprehensive list and test results/summaries. I think I've decided to purchase neither at this time and will investigate other options.

 

[Kevin C Brown]