I read that review a few days ago. My opinion on it: as well. I got a out of this reviewer's line of "The picture-quality is unaccountably bad; I've seen dollar DVDs of public domain titles look better than this $39.98 set of 15 shows." As Gary knows, I tend to be pickier than some of the older-show's collectors on this forum but that's funny, to compare general PD prints to the non-HD-remastered CBS transfers of this show. I checked out a couple of discs from S4V1 to get a fresh view of the Q. They're not as good, obviously, as the S2-3 HD-remastered sets but nowhere near general PD quality imo. If S4V2 is comparable to S4V1's transfers, I'll be glad that I didn't heed Stuart Galbraith's DVDTalk review recommendation.