DevinM
Auditioning
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2001
- Messages
- 6
I just finished watching Columbia/Tristar's above average dvd and seeing as I haven't seen one review appear on the web yet, I figure I'll toss out my views.
It goes without saying that the film is a classic, featuring excellent performances by all the principle cast, notably a young Marlon Brando. More classic lines and scenes than I can count. A definite must-see, regardless of the format. Now as for the DVD...
The video quality was average at best. While a number of scenes were perfectly crisp and clear, an even greater number exhibited specks, lines, bright spots, grain, you name it. The grain caused what I believe is called a "shimmering effect", where portions of the screen would "dance" and vary in brightness. Many other scenes exhibited poor detail and greyscale definition. Edge enhancement was prevalent. By far not the worst transfer I've ever seen, but not the best either.
The audio thankfully was miles ahead of the video. The dialogue came through clearly and at no point did I notice any excessive distortion or hiss. The Leonard Bernstein score came through perky and clean when it kicked in.
I managed to take a quick glimpse at the extras...first is a commentary with a Kazan biographer. I haven't listened but at least a commentary is present. Next up is a short "exclusive featurette" with a number of people discussing the famous "contender" scene. Finally is an interview with Elia Kazan, the film's director.
Overall a very decent dvd, and a phenominal film. If you find a good deal on this one I say go for it, but dont expect a Citizen Kane level presentation.
Film - 10/10
Video - 7/10
Audio - 9/10
It goes without saying that the film is a classic, featuring excellent performances by all the principle cast, notably a young Marlon Brando. More classic lines and scenes than I can count. A definite must-see, regardless of the format. Now as for the DVD...
The video quality was average at best. While a number of scenes were perfectly crisp and clear, an even greater number exhibited specks, lines, bright spots, grain, you name it. The grain caused what I believe is called a "shimmering effect", where portions of the screen would "dance" and vary in brightness. Many other scenes exhibited poor detail and greyscale definition. Edge enhancement was prevalent. By far not the worst transfer I've ever seen, but not the best either.
The audio thankfully was miles ahead of the video. The dialogue came through clearly and at no point did I notice any excessive distortion or hiss. The Leonard Bernstein score came through perky and clean when it kicked in.
I managed to take a quick glimpse at the extras...first is a commentary with a Kazan biographer. I haven't listened but at least a commentary is present. Next up is a short "exclusive featurette" with a number of people discussing the famous "contender" scene. Finally is an interview with Elia Kazan, the film's director.
Overall a very decent dvd, and a phenominal film. If you find a good deal on this one I say go for it, but dont expect a Citizen Kane level presentation.
Film - 10/10
Video - 7/10
Audio - 9/10