You are correct that MPI collaborated on Carnival of Souls, but they don't actually own it. Criterion has let me know that as of right now they have no plans to work on The Darjeeling Limited, whereas with The Life Aquatic they were working on it while it was still filming.
Ignoring the stuff licensed from Studio Canal, Image, Wellspring, Anchor Bay, MK2, and various European rights holders, here is a somewhat complete list of the films have been directly licensed from major American studios. I’m probably forgetting some stuff too.
Disney Armageddon Chasing Amy Indiscretion of an American Wife/Terminal Station (part of Disney’s ABC/Selznick library) The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou Notorious (part of Disney’s ABC/Selznick library - now OOP and licensed to MGM) Rebecca (part of Disney’s ABC/Selznick library - now OOP and licensed to MGM) The Rock The Royal Tenenbaums Rushmore Spellbound (part of Disney’s ABC/Selznick library - now OOP and licensed to MGM) Straw Dogs (part of Disney’s ABC/Selznick library - now OOP and licensed to MGM)
Fox 3 Women Heaven Can Wait House of Games (MGM? remains to be seen) Kagemusha The Leopard Naked Lunch Night and the City Pickup on South Street Thieves Highway Unfaithfully Yours Young Mr. Lincoln
Lionsgate Kicking and Screaming
New Line An Angel at My Table Hoop Dreams Naked Short Cuts Sid & Nancy (part of Embassy/Nelson library – now distributed by MGM) This is Spinal Tap (part of Embassy/Nelson library – now distributed by MGM)
Orion (all out of print – Orion purchased by MGM) Robocop The Silence of the Lambs The Unbearable Lightness of Being (rights reverted to Saul Zaentz – now distributed by Warner)
Paramount Ace in the Hole Days of Heaven If… Robinson Crusoe on Mars
Universal All That Heaven Allows The Bank Dick Brazil Charade (technically in PD, but elements from Universal) Dazed and Confused Do the Right Thing Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas La Haine In the Mood for Love (originally licensed from USA films – now Focus/Universal) The Killers The Lady Eve The Last Temptation of Christ My Man Godfrey (technically in PD, but elements from Universal) The Scarlet Empress Sullivan’s Travels Traffic (originally licensed from USA films – now Focus/Universal) Trouble in Paradise Under the Volcano Videodrome Written on the Wind
Even if they start to release titles in HD, there is no guarantee that Criterion will be able to release HD versions of any of the titles they've licensed from the major studios. The special features might end up being found only on the dvd.
I think the confusion is because at one time Fox did release both DISCREET CHARM and THE PHANTOM OF LIBERTY theatrically. (Producer Serge Silberman had a deal with the studio in the '70's) In fact, my ancient Image laserdisc of PHANTOM (when it was released by Media's "Cinematheque Collection") still opens with a Fox logo. I have not seen either DVD of the film, but I would not be surprised if those prints perhaps still open with a Fox fanfare, though Fox no longer owns either film.
Wow, I'm surprised to see Days Of Heaven is being put out by Criterion... maybe Badlands isn't far behind either?
And of course, I'm thrilled to see Breathless being issued as well. I've yet to pick up the Fox Lorber release so god knows I've waited long enough. Guess that paid off!
Is Under The Volcano a safe buy or should I go with a pre-rental?
To be honest, I don't think I've seen any of Huston's films post-Night Of The Iguana, but of course I've never been let down by his directorial work.
I was searching the listing on IMDB and was very surprised to see a cameo role by one Jim McCarthy... is that who I think it is?
Niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice. Those guys at Criterion really know how to do a DVD cover.
That said, my only qualm is that the figure at the bottom of the image is obviously photo-shopped in. It's odd having an artificial image representing a movie famous for it's naturalism. A minor quibble, though. I like it, definitely.