benbess
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Sep 8, 2009
- Messages
- 5,670
- Real Name
- Ben
Stephen Bowie and JoAnn Paul:
This debate has no doubt been a lot of work, for both of you, but I think each of you have added to our understanding and appreciation of Mannix. Thanks to both of you. For what little it may be worth, I find both of your perspectives worthy and illuminating—and probably in large part because they come from such different points of view.
As a Star Trek fan, I confess that a quote from The Undiscovered Country came into my mind while I was reading your posts that may or may not be relevant. In that movie, Captain Kirk is talking with Spock, and at one point says, more or less: "We're each of us extremists. Reality is somewhere in-between."
I think each of your points of view address essential elements of this classic show. For me, perhaps unrealistically, the views you express are not entirely incompatible—at least in my mind. Imho the "reality" of Mannix is probably somewhere in-between the two views that you present.
Anyway, thanks again for your work. And thanks also for being civil as you agree to disagree.
Best wishes, Ben
This debate has no doubt been a lot of work, for both of you, but I think each of you have added to our understanding and appreciation of Mannix. Thanks to both of you. For what little it may be worth, I find both of your perspectives worthy and illuminating—and probably in large part because they come from such different points of view.
As a Star Trek fan, I confess that a quote from The Undiscovered Country came into my mind while I was reading your posts that may or may not be relevant. In that movie, Captain Kirk is talking with Spock, and at one point says, more or less: "We're each of us extremists. Reality is somewhere in-between."
I think each of your points of view address essential elements of this classic show. For me, perhaps unrealistically, the views you express are not entirely incompatible—at least in my mind. Imho the "reality" of Mannix is probably somewhere in-between the two views that you present.
Anyway, thanks again for your work. And thanks also for being civil as you agree to disagree.
Best wishes, Ben