Carlo_M
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Oct 31, 1997
- Messages
- 13,392
I ask because I do like this album, and I want to buy a hi-res version. Yes, I know about the lossy hi-res dual disc fiasco, but I have to admit that the James Taylor Beacon Theater DVD, which is only DD5.1, sounds pretty damned good to my ears.
And Heavier Things adds a new wrinkle. For those who own the CD (like me) we noticed that it's recorded very "hot". When the SACD came out, some who bought it (I didn't have an SACD player at the time) reported that it was still "hot", perhaps more a product of how it was recorded.
So my question is: did they remaster it for the DualDisc 5.1 side so that it's not so hot [or overcompressed]? If so, I may go with the DualDisc version. If not, I'll probably pick up the SACD version or even stand pat with the CD version since if it really was recorded that way, hi-res'ing it will help very little.
Please let's not turn this into a DualDisc vs. SACD/DVD-A thread. I realize that I would rather have SACD/DVD-A than Dual(y)Disc. But I want this particular album in the best sounding format possible, and if the SACD is still hot/overcompressed, but they remixed or remastered it better for the Dual(y)Disc(o) version, then for this one album I will buy that format.
Thanks!
And Heavier Things adds a new wrinkle. For those who own the CD (like me) we noticed that it's recorded very "hot". When the SACD came out, some who bought it (I didn't have an SACD player at the time) reported that it was still "hot", perhaps more a product of how it was recorded.
So my question is: did they remaster it for the DualDisc 5.1 side so that it's not so hot [or overcompressed]? If so, I may go with the DualDisc version. If not, I'll probably pick up the SACD version or even stand pat with the CD version since if it really was recorded that way, hi-res'ing it will help very little.
Please let's not turn this into a DualDisc vs. SACD/DVD-A thread. I realize that I would rather have SACD/DVD-A than Dual(y)Disc. But I want this particular album in the best sounding format possible, and if the SACD is still hot/overcompressed, but they remixed or remastered it better for the Dual(y)Disc(o) version, then for this one album I will buy that format.
Thanks!