Directors It's elementary, my dear Watson - a mystery movies tournament (1 Viewer)

[Jim_K]

And Then There Were None
Bad Day at Black Rock - close
The Big Sleep - Roger Rabbit hasn't aged well
Vertigo

 

[Bill McA]

And Then There Were None
The Wicker Man
The Big Sleep
Vertigo

 

[george kaplan]

Witness for the Proscecution

Abstain

The Big Sleep - completely disagree with Jim about Roger Rabbit which is still one of the greatest films ever made, but against The Big Sleep...

Vertigo

 

[John C. Wilson]

Witness for the Proscecution
Bad Day at Black Rock
Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
Vertigo

 

[Walter Kittel]

The Big Sleep
Vertigo - tough draw for Body Double which might be my favorite DePalma film.

- Walter.

 

[Brook K]

The Wicker Man
The Big Sleep
Vertigo

Fabulous experience seeing Vertigo at the Arclight in Hollywood last night.

 

[Lew Crippen]

abstain

 

[Steeve Bergeron]

Vertigo

 

[Arman]

The Big Sleep

 

[Agee Bassett]

And Then There Were None
Bad Day at Black Rock
The Big Sleep
Vertigo

 

[SteveGon]

My votes:

And Then There Were None
The Wicker Man
The Big Sleep - Love Rog though.
Body Double - I fell and hit my head, okay?


And Then There Were None wins 4 - 2.
The Wicker Man wins 4 - 3.
The Big Sleep wins 10 - 1.
Vertigo wins 10 - 1.


Round 1 - Bracket 5

Body Heat vs. The Vanishing


Round 1 - Bracket 6

Blue Velvet vs. The Usual Suspects


Round 1 - Bracket 7

Charade vs. The 39 Steps


Round 1 - Bracket 8

Chinatown vs. The Third Man


That last one hurts...

 

[Jim_K]

Abstain - been too long since I've seen BH & not sure which Vanishing this is.
Blue Velvet - not a fan of The Usual Suspects
Charade - The 39 Steps didn't impress me that much. Maybe I'll give it another chance in the future.
The Third Man

 

[SteveGon]

That's the original The Vanishing.

 

[Nick Sievers]

Abstain
Blue Velvet
The 39 Steps
The Third Man

 

[george kaplan]

Abstain

Abstain - seen both, couldn't care less which one wins this bracket

Charade - very tough

Chinatown - both are great, but Chinatown is clearly superior

 

[Brook K]

Blue Velvet - easy
The 39 Steps - Not very high on my Hitchcock list but still better than Charade
Chinatown - I don't know if I would call either great, but I agree with the gist of what George said.

 

[Bill J]

The Vanishing
abstain - both are awful
The 39 Steps
The Third Man

 

[Bill McA]

The Vanishing
Blue Velvet
The 39 Steps
Chinatown

 

[Justin_S]

The Vanishing easily. Amazing film.

Blue Velvet- You can't beat Lynch, though I do love Suspects.

Charade

Chinatown

 

[Arman]

Blue Velvet and The Third Man (both are in my 100 greatest films ever made list) easily over their rivals