I snagged a new copy of S5 for that price too! I was thrilled and wish I could get seasons 1, 3 & 4 that cheap! I think S2 looks pretty good. But I started there and until that S5 purchase didn't have anything with which to compare. I've not finished watching S2 yet so it will be a while before I crack open S5 and see just what I'm missing with S2 but all I can say is if the others are better then wow! Keep in mind that I still watch on a 32" CRT and *lots* of stuff that looks horrible on my computers looks very good on the TV.