Saurav
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2001
- Messages
- 2,174
You're auditioning two components - let's say, preamplifiers. They cost the same, or close enough that it doesn't matter, and it's within your budget. The looks and ergonomics of both are the same, or again, close enough that you could easily live with either one. They're both made by manufacturers with equal "snob-appeal" to you and anyone you think might visit you, so that's not a factor either. (And since this is a hypothetical situation, any other external factors that might apply are also the same between the two).
One of the components has better specs on paper. Either it has better numbers for all the parameters (and they're measured the same way and reported the same way for both components), or, (and this is more likely) the two components have identical numbers for most of the specs, (or again, close enough that it doesn't matter), and one of them has better numbers than the other on the few remaining parameters.
But, you like the sound of the other one more. You've brought them both home and auditioned them on your system, with your own music, on your own time. It doesn't matter if you've performed a blind or a sighted comparision. If you're a blind test kind of a guy, you've performed a blind test; if you're not, you haven't. In other words, you've done whatever is needed to convince yourself that you prefer the sound of one over the other, and it turns out that you prefer the sound of the one with the poorer specs.
Question: Which one would you pick?
This is a very simple question, with an A/B answer. If you post to this thread, please tell us your "A or B" answer. Feel free to put down any additional explanation/disclaimer/information/anything that you feel like. However, please do not post a long response without answering the question
One of the components has better specs on paper. Either it has better numbers for all the parameters (and they're measured the same way and reported the same way for both components), or, (and this is more likely) the two components have identical numbers for most of the specs, (or again, close enough that it doesn't matter), and one of them has better numbers than the other on the few remaining parameters.
But, you like the sound of the other one more. You've brought them both home and auditioned them on your system, with your own music, on your own time. It doesn't matter if you've performed a blind or a sighted comparision. If you're a blind test kind of a guy, you've performed a blind test; if you're not, you haven't. In other words, you've done whatever is needed to convince yourself that you prefer the sound of one over the other, and it turns out that you prefer the sound of the one with the poorer specs.
Question: Which one would you pick?
This is a very simple question, with an A/B answer. If you post to this thread, please tell us your "A or B" answer. Feel free to put down any additional explanation/disclaimer/information/anything that you feel like. However, please do not post a long response without answering the question