DVD Review HTF REVIEW: Santa Clause 2 (HIGHLY RECOMMENDED)

Discussion in 'DVD' started by DaViD Boulet, Nov 20, 2003.

Tags:
  1. DaViD Boulet

    DaViD Boulet Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Feb 24, 1999
    Messages:
    8,800
    Likes Received:
    3
    [​IMG]


    SANTA
    CLAUSE
    2
    Studio:Disney Year:2003Film Length: 104 minutes Aspect Ratio:16X9 encoded 1.85:1 (separate P/S 4x3 version available)Audio:5.1 DD English Extras:7 Deleted Scenes, Making-Of Featurette, Interview with Legendary Figures (Mother Nature, Father Time, etc.), Director’s Audio Commentary, Tour of the Elf Factory video tour, Gag Reel...




    Another Christmas Movie??? A personal moment with DaViD…



    Christmas movies represent something very special to me. Every year (after Thanksgiving has passed, that’s part of the rule) I pull out my stack of Christmas DVD titles from their dedicated spot on the shelf and systematically watch them all before the New Year rolls in. Classics like It’s a Wonderful Life, A Charlie Brown Christmas, A Christmas Carol (George C. Scott), Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer, How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (Dr. Seuss’), The Bishop’s Wife, Miracle on 34 th Street, and (no Christmas movie list would be complete without it) A Christmas Story, have long held honorable positions on this list. These were films I grew up watching annually on television before their inception on DVD; They represent movies without which the Christmas season just wouldn’t be complete (my Meet Me in St. Louis laserdisc manages to get the dust brushed off of it too). Most of these films constitute memories of my childhood and so garner that added magical dimension that, through no fault of their own, newer films just can’t quite seem to catch hold of. Then again, let’s be honest folks…maybe it is their fault… Hollywood just can’t make’em like they used to. Our chance to find magic in Christmas movies can only look backward in time through sentimental eyes that romanticize the past. Newly produced “Christmas” movies are best avoided: they are squarely secular, don’t have the “heart” or sense of depth to them like movies from the good-ole-days, and in their vain attempt to entertain modern audiences they strip away the very soul of Christmas in favor of offering some new “interpretation” and so inevitably end up making a mockery of an otherwise sacred, special time.

    At least that’s what I thought until I watched Santa Clause 2. [​IMG]

    Surprising myself, for approximately two hours I experienced the joy of what it was like being seven years old again and feeling the sensation of a magic-filled movie going straight to the heart. It was mystifying--the simple, pure, and magical joy that brings with it that fresh sense of innocence you take for granted when you're young. SC2 is a genuinely charming and “sweet” movie that doesn’t loose substance by turning into a Halmark-card-cliché. Yes, folks, take it from me, if Santa Clause 2 can rekindle my jaded emotional sensibilities (imagine Blanch taking a long drag on her cigarette pausing only to take a sip of a vodka as she types), maybe it can work for you too. Santa Caluse 2 is officially now added to my Christmas-Season-Must-Watch list.

    Just what makes this film so special? After watching it completely and investigating the special features of this DVD, my suspicion is that we have Director Michael Lembeck to thank for it (THANKS).




    Story...


    A prerequisite to Santa Clause 2 is…well…Santa Clause 1. So before you plunk your new Santa Cause 2 DVD in the tray, do the experience justice by making sure you’ve watched the prequel: The Santa Clause. Tim Allen has the distinction of taking the lead in both these films and he’s wonderful. Just to be fair, in my enthusiasm to praise SC2 I did not intend to cast a negative light on the original Santa Clause film incase you’re thinking to your self: “Hey! I thought the first movie was good too!”. TSC is quite entertaining in its own right and I’m sure many of you (myself included) consider it well worth watching. I own the WS disc of “The Santa Clause SE” for this very reason (careful…available in P/S so look carefully when buying). IMO, however "good" TSC is, SC2 is even better.

    Some minor spoilers are inevitable so read the rest of this section only if thusly prepared…

    SC2 picks up the action where TSC leaves off. We’ve got our new Santa (Tim Allen) managing things up at the North Pole and doing a fine job. Then comes trouble…the fine print of the Become-the-new-Santa card reveals “The Mrs. Clause” specifying that Santa has exactly one month left to find a Mrs. Clause (get married) or else the clock is going to do a stroke-of-midnight-carriage-back-to-a-pumpkin number on him. Complicating things further, his son has managed to get onto the “naughty” list (yes, he checked it twice to be sure) and so Santa heads back “home” to try to work things out before time runs out.

    I know on paper none of this sounds particularly inspired or moving. Where the magic comes in is the way Director Michael Lembeck delivers it. I’ve identified 3 key elements that I think are part of its success (I’m sure there are more):
    1. Despite all the glitz and sparkle of the visuals, sets, and costumes, the character acting in this film is spot-on and remarkably believable. You really feel these characters, and you trust them with take-it-for-granted sense of faith you'd typically associate with a more serious drama. And these characters feel like real people...not some script-writer's puppet or formulaic invention. Even characters that at first would seem to be the typically cardboard-cut-out types like the “hardened and bitter female school principal” (played by Elizabeth Mitchell) surprise you by revealing a substantial level of depth and dimensionality. Comedies (and this is a comedy) often don’t bother to try to create characters who preserve a strong sense of realism like this. I was very impressed with the acting team (and Lembeck’s handling of them).
    2. The screenplay is good. What good is it to have good actors if the words they’re saying sound cheesy and lame? (think Phantom Menace…just had to say it, sorry…back on track now...) No scripting weakness plagues this film. Oh no. SC2 is well-written which, in combination with good acting, creates a genuinely moving experience for the viewer.
    3. Lembeck is a man with heart, and his love for this film creates a sense of magic that is tangible. There are scenes that are truly beautiful in this movie. Beautiful at a very deep level—a level of rich human experience. The scene that touched me most (some soggy tissues to prove it) was (spoiler warning…) when Allen attends the school-staff Christmas Party which is populated with adults who’ve lost touch with the Spirit of Christmas. Whipping up a bit of Santa magic, Allen begins to distribute gifts to each of the faculty members. As each gift is opened, it contains a coveted/wished-for toy from that person’s childhood, which rips right to the emotional core of the individual as well as you, the person watching. The power and simple beauty of this moment is on the level of Cary Grant pointing out the story behind the Roman coin to the old professor who's lost his inspiration (The Bishop’s Wife), or when Jimmy Stuart’s friends come pouring into his living room with donations to save his family’s firm and personal reputation (Wonderful Life), or when Linus takes the spotlight as the house-lights dim and silences the chaos of the floundering Peanut’s Christmas pageant by sharing with everyone the true meaning of Christmas. Magical moments like that are worth watching an entire movie to experience, and Santa Clause 2 has got a few of them.



    Picture...


    Thought I’d never get to this point didn’t you. [​IMG] SC2 demonstrates what good DVD mastering/compression can deliver. On my 16x9 direct-view monitor, colors are rich and vivid without any noise. Detail is clear and crisp and the image maintains a somewhat soft-film-like character while at the same time coming across with a nice sense of depth / 3-dimensionality. Black level is strong and grayscale seems to track from dark to light without any distracting banding, digital noise, or blocking. I can find absolute no trace of ringing from any artificial edge-sharpening in either the vertical or horizontal plane (maybe those guys at THX have finally figured out what we’ve been talking about [​IMG] ).

    This film is gorgeously filmed and it looks sumptuous as it should on this DVD. Many of the scenes and sets have a lot of mid-to-background picture information that detail comes across cleanly. I’m certain that a nice hi-def transfer would look even better but from just watching the DVD I’m not left feeling like I’m missing out. Good job Disney.


    Picture: 4.75/5

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    Warning! A separate P/S version of this film is also available to buy carefully!



    Sound...


    Santa Clause 2 has got the obligatory 5.1 DD sound, and manages to make legitimate use of the rear surround channels that far exceeds the typical non-action genre film soundtrack. The Elves’ workshop comes to you with an abundance of sounds finding their way to your rear speakers and the multi-channel presentation really adds to the sense of involvement with the listener. The musical score is well recorded and sounds rich and dynamic, and there is a nice sense of width to the front soundstage. Bass seems solid (mostly in musical score, but also comes in during effects) and there’s a relaxed sense of openness to the general sound.

    The only real flaw I can detect is an occasional distortion in the vocal track that sounds like the microphones or recording tape got overloaded during session recording. It only happens a few times when someone talks loudly or yells and it’s not any cause to call 1-800-Disney and complain, but I do need to mention it here (and knock-off a point in our final sound score to reflect).

    Putting it all together …

    Sound: 4/5

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]


    Special Features...


    After making such fuss over how much I enjoyed this movie earlier I’ll try to tone it down here, but I do gotta say that the extras on this disc impressed me about as much as the film itself and for a particular reason: They keep in character with the Santa Story…to the point that they purport that this film was shot not with “actors”, but with the real legendary characters (and locations) themselves. Yes, folks, you can imagine the logistical nightmare Disney underwent to get through all that red tape and truck all that equipment up to the Toy Factory at the North Pole.

    Not only does this “angle” add a humorous and entertaining second-level to the bonus material for adults, but it perpetuates the “magic” you’re left with after having watched the film and doesn’t dispel any Santa myths for the youngsters to watch it with you.

    [*]Director’s Commentary. If you had any doubts about how much Director Michael Lembeck truly loves this movie, you certainly won’t after spending some time with him listening to his running commentary. In several of the key-scenes I auditioned he really gets into the meat of his movie making and what he was thinking and why he made the decisions that he made (edit: though in many "lesser" scenes he spends more time having fun perpetuating the "reality" of the whole Santa/North-Pole Elves-workshop thing and doesn't focus so much on the process of actual filmmaking--fun for the kids but probably not as much for the adult film-critic). This man is the real deal and loves what he does. Listening to him talk about his movie makes you feel it too. As if I hadn’t gone through enough tissues watching those “touching” scenes in context during the movie…I found myself reaching for them again listing to Limbeck’s talk about them! If you make it through the “gift giving” scene listening to his commentary and don’t cry you’re a stronger man than I am (or your made of stone).
    [*]We get seven deleted scenes with or without the director’s commentary. Honestly, many of these scenes were beautifully crafted and would have really enriched the final film…some having been cut only for “time” reasons. Lembeck…count me in for a director’s cut where you branch them back into the movie! I hope in the future more directors take a “Lord of the Rings” approach and start to view the DVD medium as a chance to complete their “true vision” for their film rather than feeling obliged to maintain the same compromises (like run-time) they felt they needed to make for the theater. In any case, thanks Disney/Lembeck for providing us with these great deleted scenes in one way or another. I’ve “imagined” them back in sequence in the film myself for the time being. [​IMG]
    [*]Gag reel. Cute but not earth-shattering.
    [*]Operation Toy Box: Save Santa. Didn’t check it out. Hey…the disc is out now so you get and let everyone else know the scoop.[/b]
    [*]True Confessions of the Legendary Figures. This is a real hoot. Some of the characters who participate in this film are Mother Nature, Father Time, the Easter Bunny and oft mis-represented (as you’ll discover) Tooth Fairy. This featurette assembles interviews with these legendary figures (remember, they’re real) to discuss issues like what they liked most about participating in the film or what they found challenging. I challenge you not to laugh outloud.
    [*]Director’s Tour of Elfsburg Featurette. Take a behind the scenes tour of the Elves’ toy factory. Yes, again all “in character” with the whole Santa thing and very entertaining. I think kids will especially enjoy this one.[/list]

    In Closing...


    In my humble opinion, there’s a new Christmas Classic for Parents, children, and everyone else to enjoy for years to come and become part of a family tradition. If you enjoy the occasional charming Christmas story, or love Tim Allen, or just want to test-drive a seasonal comedy that’s got some real heart, you heard it here:


    HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
     
  2. BruceKimmel

    BruceKimmel Stunt Coordinator

    Joined:
    Jun 9, 2003
    Messages:
    165
    Likes Received:
    0
    Glad to hear it's such a good DVD. Should I reveal here that thirty-three years ago Mr. Lembeck was my best man at my wedding? His father was the wonderful Harvey (Erich von Zipper and Sgt. Bilko series). Should I reveal here that Mr. Lembeck played Bud Frump to my J. Pierpont Finch in How to Succeed? Should I reveal here that it was between the two of us to play MacKenzie Phillips' husband in One Day at a Time and HE got the part?
     
  3. DaViD Boulet

    DaViD Boulet Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Feb 24, 1999
    Messages:
    8,800
    Likes Received:
    3
    You should. [​IMG] (it's a small world theme song playing in my mind...)

    Bruce, I'd love to here more about this guy. He seems so amazingly cool from the extras on the DVD and seems like such a genuine from-the-heart sort of person. Feel free to share anything you'd like you think would nice to know. Clearly this man is the force responsible for making this movie the wonderful work of art that it is and I'd love to hear more about him...UNLESS that is that I'm totally off base and he's really a jerk and finding out the truth would totally ruin the film forever for me [​IMG]

    Oh, and *you* sound pretty darn interesting yourself! Go on and give some dish...
     
  4. Kenneth Cummings

    Kenneth Cummings Supporting Actor

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2001
    Messages:
    852
    Likes Received:
    0
    That was a great review. I bought a copy of Santa Clause 2 for my mom for christmas (widescreen of course [​IMG]), but I might pick up a copy for my own after watching it. Besides, my Santa Clause SE from last year might feel lonly if I don't get it brother.
     
  5. Chris_Morris

    Chris_Morris Screenwriter

    Joined:
    Jan 4, 2002
    Messages:
    1,887
    Likes Received:
    0
    Great review David [​IMG]

    The original movie was great, but this is one of those rare cases when a sequel truly outshines the first. And the fact that they used the 8 year time difference (when it truly was 8 years between films) and got the same actor to play the kid just made it that much better.


    Chris
     
  6. BruceKimmel

    BruceKimmel Stunt Coordinator

    Joined:
    Jun 9, 2003
    Messages:
    165
    Likes Received:
    0
    Michael is a very nice guy and always has been. We haven't kept in touch that much in recent years (I'm actually very good friends with his ex-wife). Michael spent years doing television, especially Friends. He is a very genuine person - we were really close back in our college days and went everywhere together. I'm really glad for him. I made my film directorial debut in 1975 and he was always amazed that I'd actually gotten the money together to make a low budget film and that it actually sold to Paramount. I know he was always moving in that direction and after he won his Emmy for Friends I know that he was really looking to make a movie, and I also know that he was smart enough to wait around for the right one. I know that he has a very strong sense of family, which definitely comes out in the film.

    I was thinking back to the cast we had in our college production of How To Succeed at LACC - me, him, Linda Hart (most recently on Broadway in Hairspray, and she's been in a lot of Clint Eastwood's films), Annette Charles (Chachi or whatever her name was in the film of Grease) and Margo Rogers who was then married to an up-and-coming singer named Kenny Rogers.
     
  7. Tim Glover

    Tim Glover Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Jan 12, 1999
    Messages:
    7,996
    Likes Received:
    260
    Location:
    Monroe, LA
    Real Name:
    Tim Glover
    Nice review David. I do think the original SC is better, but this is still a nice surprise that a sequel of this type is very good.

    Keep up the good work. [​IMG]
     
  8. Rocky F

    Rocky F Second Unit

    Joined:
    Jun 13, 2002
    Messages:
    371
    Likes Received:
    0
    My wife picked this up today and opened it up and found two passes for "Haunted Mansion" but the box just indicated that it would have one. Is this normal, or did we luck out?
     
  9. RyanChristoffel

    Joined:
    Oct 21, 2002
    Messages:
    26
    Likes Received:
    0
    Funny, the copy I got didn't come with any "Haunted Mansion" passes. Didn't say anything about it on the box either. [​IMG]
     
  10. Jeff Adams

    Jeff Adams Screenwriter

    Joined:
    Dec 13, 1999
    Messages:
    1,549
    Likes Received:
    0
     
  11. Eric Emma

    Eric Emma Supporting Actor

    Joined:
    Feb 18, 2003
    Messages:
    508
    Likes Received:
    0
    Interesting... I passed on this in it theatrical run because I loved the orignal but thought this would merely tarnish it so I will check this movie out as soon as possible, I made a blind buy on Sleeping Beauty based on Dave Review on that and I loved it. So if I don't rent it first, I'll proberly pick it up.
     
  12. Chris_Morris

    Chris_Morris Screenwriter

    Joined:
    Jan 4, 2002
    Messages:
    1,887
    Likes Received:
    0
    Just watched this and have to thank David for pointing out the audio distortion. Without this review, I would have sworn that my tweeter was messed up. On my setup it was very noticable any time Tim Allen's voice got really loud. Especially during the faculty party, and the credit roll.


    Chris
     
  13. Mike Frezon

    Mike Frezon Moderator
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Oct 9, 2001
    Messages:
    38,487
    Likes Received:
    5,748
    Location:
    Rensselaer, NY
    Sorry, Dave. On this one we disagree. But, like a friend of mine always says whenever we disagree on something -- that's why they still make chocolate AND vanilla.

    This was a blind buy for me. The three things that put me over the top: David's review, I enjoyed the original SC, and the Haunted Mansion coupon.

    I can say the video transfer looked great.

    I found this movie rather juvenile and contrived. I did not find the original to be so. My wife, 13-year old son and I all watched it together for the first time and we were all stunned by how bad it was. My son called it the "lamest thing he's ever seen." I've read some reviews that herald the use of the same child actor as Charlie, Scott's son. He was really, really awful. Really. Awful. Oh, and the plot was pretty bad, too.

    But, I just re-read David's review to see if I could figure out where I went wrong and all I can come up with is....

    ....chocolate and vanilla. [​IMG]
     
  14. DaViD Boulet

    DaViD Boulet Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Feb 24, 1999
    Messages:
    8,800
    Likes Received:
    3
     
  15. Colin Jacobson

    Colin Jacobson Producer

    Joined:
    Apr 19, 2000
    Messages:
    5,928
    Likes Received:
    498
     
  16. DaViD Boulet

    DaViD Boulet Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Feb 24, 1999
    Messages:
    8,800
    Likes Received:
    3
    Colin,

    Very interesting. I didn't listen to the running commentary for the entire length of the film...I picked about 4 "key scenes" that I thought were interesting and watched them (about 15-20 minutes worth total) with commentary and I guess I lucked out--his discussion about lighting, filming, choice of actors and acting approaches seemed to really dominate in the scenes where I listened.

    Maybe his discussion of the scenes I picked was a loaded choice because those scenes *were* key scenes.

    Next time I'll try to do a more random sampling of the disc from start to finish to get a better feel without biasing my choice towards any particular scene choice (or do a bit of both)...

    -dave [​IMG]

    edit: listened to more of the commentary focusing on "normal" scenes and I get where Colin is coming from. I've edited my review regarding the commentary slightly to reflect...I hope it seems more in balance now with the overall presentation and presents more clearly where I'm coming from...
     
  17. Jake Lipson

    Jake Lipson Supporting Actor

    Joined:
    Dec 21, 2002
    Messages:
    563
    Likes Received:
    56
    The original Santa Clause is good, solid, enjoyable fun, even if there have been better Disney Christmas movies before it (The Nightmare Before Christmas anyone?) Anyway, I did have fun with the original and I always meant to see this during its theatrical run. But...it slipped past me because of all the more important films this time last year (Harry Potter, Die Another Day, Treasure Planet, Chicago, Catch Me If You Can, Evelyn, and most of all The Two Towers.) However, I will probably be renting this soon and am looking forward to seeing it. Great review David! Thanks!

    I must note to Disney though that I am disappointed in the fact that the Santa Clause double pack is available in P&S only. While I know they are available seperately, I would have been more inclinded to buy SC2 blind if it was with the original, and I won't buy either in P&S.

    ----------
    Side Notes

    I wonder if Pirates of the Carribbean will come with a Mansion ticket too? It seems more appropriate to package that with, seeing as they're ride movie and SC is...not.

    David - have you recieved your review copy of Pirates of the Carribbean yet? I'm really looking forward to your review of that one. It's my second favorite movie of the year thus far and the only review as of yet is an R2 review that focuses mainly on extras. I'm most concerned with the picture, since they've crammed 3 commentaries and DD5.1 and DTS tracks on one disc with a longish movie. When can we expect your review? Thanks!
     
  18. DaViD Boulet

    DaViD Boulet Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Feb 24, 1999
    Messages:
    8,800
    Likes Received:
    3
    Jake,

    No Pirates DVD yet! I've been sent plenty of promotional literature so hopefully it'll be coming any day now...

    also have to post my Alias Season 2 review which, in case anyone is wondering, has a *much improved* picture quality over last season's set.
     
  19. Jack Shappa

    Jack Shappa Second Unit

    Joined:
    Jan 24, 2003
    Messages:
    411
    Likes Received:
    0
    We enjoyed it overall, but it really isn't in the same league as SC1. In fact some of the scenes had me cringing in my seat they were so bad.

    I'm glad you mentioned the distortion during a couple points (people yelling) because I heard that distortion/crackle too and thought "crap what's up with my system!?" even though I was at 10 under ref.

    - Jack
     

Share This Page