SamT
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2010
- Messages
- 5,827
- Real Name
- Sam
Saw "How Your Mother Met Me" episode. It was a great episode. 8/10. Finally the first good episode of this season.
From the Thomas and Bays AMA:Chip_HT said:I got distracted by the gross continuity error. The screen said April 2008, but it was St. Patrick's Day.
100% agreed. For the first time in what feels like a long time, the five regulars all had something compelling to do in terms of the overall story. I felt something for all of them, having been on both ends of the Lily/Marshall argument, having to really bare my soul to someone I really didn't want to and giving up something that had defined me for so long.Josh Dial said:I thought this was a fantastic episode, with each of the male leads delivering some really great performances. Josh Radnor putting in probably his best in a few seasons. This show is at its best when it has a little heart, as it did tonight (and last week, of course).
I gave up on this show last year. Just seemed to be dragging things out to extend into another season. Compare it to the Mary Tyler Moore show which went out gracefully in the 70s. This show should have ended a year or two ago.Jason_V said:100% agreed. For the first time in what feels like a long time, the five regulars all had something compelling to do in terms of the overall story. I felt something for all of them, having been on both ends of the Lily/Marshall argument, having to really bare my soul to someone I really didn't want to and giving up something that had defined me for so long.
A really great episode.
The issue is that nine out of ten posts (seriously, check this thread and the previous one) feature no discussion whatsoever, and simply state the show ought to have ended years ago. If you are going to state the same thing over and over, perhaps a more nuanced set of comments is appropriate. Otherwise, you can understand the reception...Stan said:Wow guys. Just making a brief comment. Isn't that what this forum is meant for?I've been a member here for over 15 years, joined up back when DVDs were first being released, the whole DIVX, Circuit City fiasco.Relax, we can all get along just fine.