From my viewpoint, she was trying to point out that "yodel-girl" wasn't being authentic. That she wasn't being herself. She indicated that she saw her outside, and the person that auditioned was TOTALLY different. Basically, she was putting on an act or something. (I can see a carefully-created "persona" being created for that girl by her seeminly overzealous Mom.) Regardless, I think there is some talent there that can be harnessed, so I'm glad Randy sent her through. What the hell was with that 18-year old punk throwing water on Simon? Yah, THAT kind of action will get you far if you want to be a performer. (Which there is no danger of...) The moment he did it, I thought "hey, that is technically a case of assault!" I was glad to see that he was escorted out, and talked to by the cops. At least Simon didn't press charges (which would have been stupid and bad publicity)... I'm guessing Simon was just glad to be done in Houston.