A Few Words About A few words about...™ The Lord of the Rings Trilogy - Extended Edition -- in Blu-ray

Discussion in 'Blu-ray and UHD' started by Robert Harris, Jun 14, 2011.

  1. Mark Booth

    Mark Booth Screenwriter
    Supporter

    Joined:
    Aug 25, 1999
    Messages:
    1,427
    Likes Received:
    554
    Robert,

    Please take a closer look at the scene when Gandalf first arrives at Bilbo Baggins' front door in Fellowship of the Ring. During one closeup of Gandalf's face, the clouds have disappeared and it's nothing but blue sky behind him. On the EE Blu-ray, is the sky behind him a realistic shade of blue? Does his robe and beard appear to have an excessive green tint?

    The screen caps that have been circulating for the last couple of days show (what most are agreeing is) too much of a green or cyan tint to the entire image, particularly during any scenes in the shire.

    This video of the scene in question supposedly shows the comparison of the theatrical edition Blu-ray to the extended edition Blu-ray:



    Supposedly, the green or cyan tint is something that Jackson approved. If the EE Blu-ray looks like the left side of that video, I find it very very hard to believe that Jackson gave it the OK.

    Mark
     
  2. Craig S

    Craig S Producer
    Supporter

    Joined:
    Mar 4, 2000
    Messages:
    5,711
    Likes Received:
    184
    Location:
    League City, Texas
    Real Name:
    Craig Seanor
    Bill Hunt's review is up at the Bits:

    http://www.thedigitalbits.com/reviewshd/bdreviews061411.html

    He gives 19 (out of 20) to all three films for PQ. Says they really benefit from being split over two discs.

    Here's what he says re: the color timing:




    Has the source of these screen grabs been identified? I haven't read anything yet that attributes the grabs to any particular site or reviewer.
     
  3. MatS

    MatS Screenwriter

    Joined:
    Jan 24, 2000
    Messages:
    1,599
    Likes Received:
    0
     
  4. Vincent_P

    Vincent_P Screenwriter

    Joined:
    Sep 13, 2003
    Messages:
    1,871
    Likes Received:
    203
    It's MIDDLE EARTH- a fictional fantasy realm populated by Wizards, Orks, Hobbits, Dragons, various demons, etc. etc. etc...

    It's NOT SUPPOSED to look like reality!

    Vincent



     
  5. litlgi74

    litlgi74 Auditioning

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2011
    Messages:
    5
    Likes Received:
    0
    Here is a closer... more detailed examination of the differences between the FOTR EE BD and TTT EE BD (flash back) scenes... as well as other comparisons.



    FOTR EE BD vs TTT EE BD (Flash Back) The FOTR EE BD is way when compared with the FOTR EE DVD
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59615
    FOTR TE BD vs TTT TE BD (Flash Back) What most would have expected after seeing the EE DVDs (see next link)
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59616
    and just for kicks...
    FOTR EE DVD vs TTT EE DVD (Flash Back)
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59620
    Check out the massive differences between FOTR TE BD vs FOTR EE BD... very little in TTT TE BD vs TTT EE BD
    FOTR TE BD vs FOTR EE BD
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59618
    TTT TE BD vs TTT EE BD
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59619
    And if you really want to fry your brain... Check out these DVD Vs BDs (I increased the resolution ob the DVDs to 1080p in PS...) the levels were bumped up when saving because of the format change.
    FOTR EE DVD vs FOTR EE BD... Look how dramatic the color and density shifts are between the two... just like in FOTR TE BD vs FOTR EE BD.
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59622
    FOTR EE DVD vs FOTR TE BD... I think it's important to not that the color really doesn't change much in this comparison.
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59625
    TTT EE DVD vs TTT EE BD... nor does the color really doesn't change much in this comparison.
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59623
    But let us not forget where blue snow cones come from...
    FOTR TE BD vs FOTR EE BD
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59621
    In summary... the only version that sticks out like a sore thumb when compared with all the other editions... is FOTR EE BD.
    __________________
     
  6. Paul_Scott

    Paul_Scott Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Jul 19, 2002
    Messages:
    6,546
    Likes Received:
    1

    Yeah. Middle Earth is supposed to look like the Transformers, which is supposed to look like Captain America, which is supposed to look like Rise Of The Planet Of The Apes, which is supposed to look like every other mother f*#@king movie out there now.

    Nothing takes me out of a movie these days faster than seeing all this hyper unnatural color grading. It's like movies are being made for children with very limited palates. Everything is either super sweet or super sour. No place any more for nuance and subtlety.
     
  7. oscar_merkx

    oscar_merkx Lead Actor

    Joined:
    Apr 15, 2002
    Messages:
    7,632
    Likes Received:
    1
    Cool interview
     
  8. Robert Harris

    Robert Harris Archivist
    Reviewer

    Joined:
    Feb 8, 1999
    Messages:
    9,257
    Likes Received:
    5,132
    Real Name:
    Robert Harris
    Quote:

    To my eye, there may be a point or two toward cyan-blue, but nothing like what I'm seeing in the youtube example. Skies are generally a pleasant blue, flesh tones, even for non-humans are normal, greens are strong. I presume they're not in Kansas anymore.

    Detail is superb, recognizing the fact that we're dealing with 2k.

    I'm seeing no problems whatsoever. A beautiful and satisfying image.

    Projected via a JVC RS50 recently tuned by my go-to expert Kevin Miller, on a Stewart white 1.3. Here's documentation:







    RAH
     
  9. Robert Harris

    Robert Harris Archivist
    Reviewer

    Joined:
    Feb 8, 1999
    Messages:
    9,257
    Likes Received:
    5,132
    Real Name:
    Robert Harris
    Quote:

    I concur with Mr. Hunt.

    RAH
     
  10. litlgi74

    litlgi74 Auditioning

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2011
    Messages:
    5
    Likes Received:
    0
    Hello Mr. Harris,

    So you are saying with your version of FOTR...

    You don't see the tremendous color change from TE to EE?

    Which what does your snow look like, White (TE), or Cyan (EE)?

    FOTR TE BD vs FOTR EE BD
    http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/59621

    Thanks
     
  11. Bob_S.

    Bob_S. Supporting Actor

    Joined:
    Mar 4, 2004
    Messages:
    841
    Likes Received:
    199
    I watched FOTR last night at a theater and I thought it looked fantastic. I don't remember the snow scene looking that blue but on the other hand I wasn't looking for it either.
     
  12. Mike Frezon

    Mike Frezon Moderator
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Oct 9, 2001
    Messages:
    38,077
    Likes Received:
    5,538
    Location:
    Rensselaer, NY
    John:

    Did you produce those screen grabs yourself? Or, did you just port them over from screenshotcomparison.com?

    I guess what I'm really wondering is: have you seen the actual blu-ray discs of FotR yourself?

    It seems like every major release that comes out has some "sky is falling" screengrab alert before the discs hit the street and that many times it turns out there is some anomaly in the grabs themselves.

    So, for us interested bystanders we have--on the one hand--Robert Harris and Bill Hunt giving the new FotR transfer extremely high grades and then--on the other hand--we've got these obviously color-skewed screenshots. That's why I'm wondering if you've seen the new blu discs yourself or are just repeating what others are putting up?

    Thanks.
     
  13. TheBat

    TheBat Producer

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 1999
    Messages:
    3,088
    Likes Received:
    28
    Real Name:
    Jacob
    I had the same reaction. if anything it looked great.
    nothing to really worry about.

    Jacob
     
  14. Mark Booth

    Mark Booth Screenwriter
    Supporter

    Joined:
    Aug 25, 1999
    Messages:
    1,427
    Likes Received:
    554
    Folks, I don't know about the rest of you but Robert's opinion is the one I've been waiting for. If he doesn't see a huge color shift then that's good enough for me! Particularly since he evaluated the Bilbo Baggins' front door scene compared to the side-by-side (supposed EE and TE) video that's on youtube.

    Thank you, Robert!

    Mark
     
  15. Guest

    I think I'll wait for a boxed set with both versions and maybe the Hobbit. I know, it will probably be a few years but I have the blus of the TE and the dvds of the EE to tide me over. Spectacular movies that I am proud to have seen during their original runs. Sure to become film classics.
     
  16. Jarod M

    Jarod M Stunt Coordinator

    Joined:
    Aug 16, 2000
    Messages:
    180
    Likes Received:
    0
    Ok. Go ahead and name all these major releases with the "sky is falling" screengrabs that turned out to be some anomaly in the grabs themselves. The Ten Commandments screenshots were not by one of the established authorities in the area, and they were quickly found to be faulty.

    Some people like to forget some of the glowing reviews of discs that turned out to have problems. Screenshots are just one perspective, but as long as they are accurately grabbed from a legitimate source, they as good an indicator for knowing what a disc looks like as any review, and actually they are more objective. I utilize both screenshots and reviews. I believe it is foolhardy to simply bash one or the other, because neither one is perfect.

    It appears now that the screenshots come from a source that looks different from what RAH is seeing, and also different from what was shown at last night's screening. Now it needs to be established that there aren't any faulty discs out there. It seems unlikely that only some discs would have the messed up coloring, but it was also unlikely that the colors would be intentionally or unintentionally altered in such a fashion on whatever source was used for those screenshots. Is it possible that a bad batch of discs went out, perhaps in another region???
     
  17. cafink

    cafink Producer

    Joined:
    Apr 19, 1999
    Messages:
    3,047
    Likes Received:
    36
    Real Name:
    Carl Fink
    Yeah, I couldn't think of very many cases where a problem discovered via screenshots turned out to be "some anomaly in the grabs themselves." You've mentioned The Ten Commandments, and I remember there were some issues with the color on DVD Beaver's Contact screenshots, but are there any others?
     
  18. Mike Frezon

    Mike Frezon Moderator
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Oct 9, 2001
    Messages:
    38,077
    Likes Received:
    5,538
    Location:
    Rensselaer, NY
    My only intent in asking the question was to determine the origin of the screencaps. That's all. If we find out they are, indeed, from an "established authority in the area" then I guess we have to wait and see who is closer to the mark in describing whether the image on the disc is a faithful reproduction of the film. And I'm only asking because of the apparent difference of opinion. I'm not taking sides. Just trying to figure things out.

    My "anomaly" remark could be interpreted as overly dramatic. I only meant to say that there have been occasions when screengrabs have looked one way and the moving image on the disc have appeared differently. I am no authority on such matters. I've never pretended to be and my gear doesn't allow me to be. And I often check out DVDBeaver.com when I am trying to get info on releases.

    My question was only meant to ascertain the source of the screengrabs. Nothing further should be inferred.
     
  19. Colin Jacobson

    Colin Jacobson Producer

    Joined:
    Apr 19, 2000
    Messages:
    5,916
    Likes Received:
    490
    I compared the theatrical BD and the EE BD side by side. The latter's definitely greener, but it's not insanely greener. I really don't think I'd have noticed a difference if I wasn't looking for it...
     
  20. litlgi74

    litlgi74 Auditioning

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2011
    Messages:
    5
    Likes Received:
    0

Share This Page