@Oliver
I agree, there is more to it than just having the equipment set up correctly, the person doing the review has to spot the issues if they are present, many people/reviewers miss edge enhancement even though their equipment is setup correctly and they are sitting a reasonable distance from the screen, it's a pet hate of mine, some reviewers actually LIKE excessive digital noise reduction, see some Disney reviews as proof of that, although maybe they just like it when it's animation.
So you have to take into account not only the equipment but the reviewer and that isn't always easy, i trust very few reviewers to get it right all the time, i can say i think many get it wrong too often and are reluctant to admit when it does happen.
I agree, there is more to it than just having the equipment set up correctly, the person doing the review has to spot the issues if they are present, many people/reviewers miss edge enhancement even though their equipment is setup correctly and they are sitting a reasonable distance from the screen, it's a pet hate of mine, some reviewers actually LIKE excessive digital noise reduction, see some Disney reviews as proof of that, although maybe they just like it when it's animation.
So you have to take into account not only the equipment but the reviewer and that isn't always easy, i trust very few reviewers to get it right all the time, i can say i think many get it wrong too often and are reluctant to admit when it does happen.