- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,424
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
The great John Ford's Rio Grande (1950), was the final installment of his cavalry trilogy -- the others being Fort Apache (1948) and She Wore a Yellow Ribbon (1949). Like the others, a beautiful film, this one photographed by the incomparable Bert Glennon, who between 1935 and 1959, shot eight films for Mr. Ford.
Olive's new Blu-ray, while finally allowing us to view the film in quality via Blu-ray is imperfect.
While there is no rationale for the use of window boxing for main titles on Blu-ray, that's the format we're given. Even if this were an older master, it would have been an easy fix to re-instate the credits in their full and proper format. Unfortunately, this is something that never fails to remind me that I'm not watching film. And this Blu-ray is film-like.
In a general sense, this transfer is very pleasing. Grain appears natural, with good blacks, grays, and shadow detail. I like it.
Dirt is a bit of problem, but minimal. Had someone bothered to give the transfer a minimal number of hours of clean-up, even 10, the Blu-ray could have appeared far more finished. There are some huge chunks of dirt left on the film for us to ponder.
The series of releases is apparently produced in a cookie cutter fashion, as the featurette, which I presume is a carry over, as it comes up in the wrong aspect ratio, and inferior quality, is aptly entitled Making of High Noon in the menu.
My only other annoyance is the waste of paper for the extremely cheap slipcase. Why bother if it simply replicates what's on the packaging, and allows the case to slip out when you pick it up? Seems senseless.
With just a bit more attention to the HD master, Rio Grande could have been a stellar Blu-ray. Not that its bad, but it would have taken so little to raise it up.
Image - 3.5
Audio - 4
Without the window boxing, this would have received a recommendation. It does not.
RAH
Olive's new Blu-ray, while finally allowing us to view the film in quality via Blu-ray is imperfect.
While there is no rationale for the use of window boxing for main titles on Blu-ray, that's the format we're given. Even if this were an older master, it would have been an easy fix to re-instate the credits in their full and proper format. Unfortunately, this is something that never fails to remind me that I'm not watching film. And this Blu-ray is film-like.
In a general sense, this transfer is very pleasing. Grain appears natural, with good blacks, grays, and shadow detail. I like it.
Dirt is a bit of problem, but minimal. Had someone bothered to give the transfer a minimal number of hours of clean-up, even 10, the Blu-ray could have appeared far more finished. There are some huge chunks of dirt left on the film for us to ponder.
The series of releases is apparently produced in a cookie cutter fashion, as the featurette, which I presume is a carry over, as it comes up in the wrong aspect ratio, and inferior quality, is aptly entitled Making of High Noon in the menu.
My only other annoyance is the waste of paper for the extremely cheap slipcase. Why bother if it simply replicates what's on the packaging, and allows the case to slip out when you pick it up? Seems senseless.
With just a bit more attention to the HD master, Rio Grande could have been a stellar Blu-ray. Not that its bad, but it would have taken so little to raise it up.
Image - 3.5
Audio - 4
Without the window boxing, this would have received a recommendation. It does not.
RAH