- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,407
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Finally, with College (1927), the release of Kino Lorber's Blu-ray's of Buster Keaton's non-studio work, comes to a close. And along with that final film, a boxed set, which encompasses the entire Kino / Keaton library, inclusive of shorts.
I'd like to be able to say that the boxed set is a great buy, it's currently listed at $245 at Amazon, which means that College comes along for $15 more than purchasing the films separately. As is Amazon's M.O., the price may decrease when the set is released. So the discount for purchasing the box isn't huge. What is huge is the important of the films found within, which are worth far more than the price of admission.
A couple of things are at play here. There are some interesting Holiday gift packages for the cinephile for 2012,, but few for the aficionado of the silent cinema. For that purpose, this set will stand out. The downside is that for the serious collector, I'd be willing to bet that many of the single releases are already in libraries.
For those who don't have these films, the boxed set is a blessing, as it enables collectors to have all of the films in one place -- public domain as well as those still under copyright. Interestingly, copyright seems to have little function over quality. For those who already have many of the films, College will be made available as a separate release next year.
This is an important boxed set, which along with the standard def TCM release of Keaton's M-G-M films, allows us to study the work of a master again and again.
Image and audio (music track) quality on these film varies hugely, especially when you get back to the shorts. Even in the feature library, most elements appear to be derived from prints of varying quality. Also, the later releases seem to have been handled better for HD mastering, with far fewer digital artifacts. The scores go from reasonable and ordinary to the sublime (Carl Davis).
Image - 1.5 - 3.5 (average 2.75)
Some of the greatest films every created.
Very Highly Recommended.
RAH
I'd like to be able to say that the boxed set is a great buy, it's currently listed at $245 at Amazon, which means that College comes along for $15 more than purchasing the films separately. As is Amazon's M.O., the price may decrease when the set is released. So the discount for purchasing the box isn't huge. What is huge is the important of the films found within, which are worth far more than the price of admission.
A couple of things are at play here. There are some interesting Holiday gift packages for the cinephile for 2012,, but few for the aficionado of the silent cinema. For that purpose, this set will stand out. The downside is that for the serious collector, I'd be willing to bet that many of the single releases are already in libraries.
For those who don't have these films, the boxed set is a blessing, as it enables collectors to have all of the films in one place -- public domain as well as those still under copyright. Interestingly, copyright seems to have little function over quality. For those who already have many of the films, College will be made available as a separate release next year.
This is an important boxed set, which along with the standard def TCM release of Keaton's M-G-M films, allows us to study the work of a master again and again.
Image and audio (music track) quality on these film varies hugely, especially when you get back to the shorts. Even in the feature library, most elements appear to be derived from prints of varying quality. Also, the later releases seem to have been handled better for HD mastering, with far fewer digital artifacts. The scores go from reasonable and ordinary to the sublime (Carl Davis).
Image - 1.5 - 3.5 (average 2.75)
Some of the greatest films every created.
Very Highly Recommended.
RAH