I just watched this last night and because of this review (and Peter Bracke's) I was expecting a very sharp picture. I found this to be very soft - pretty much the same as David and Andrew. If I had walked into the room mid film, I wouldn't immediately know it was in HD. I expect more from...
Watched this last night and had to pick my jaw up from the floor. Absolutely perfect imo. This is what I expect from HD. I'd like all the peeps that think Pearl Harbor looks good to see this. :-)
To all of you who think this title actually looks good, I have a question: - what size screen are you watching it on? I was very bummed at how this looked personally. Way too much noise, detail only average at best.
I actually think it's one of the stronger Blu-ray titles. I love the look of this film. It's got a gritty look, but the grain doesn't interfere with detail - in contrast to Pearl Harbor where excessive grain mars detail.
It *might* be available from Amazon. They have the regular DVD version released in 2005 and another one with sketchy details released last month - which has some description that includes "high-definition". Although the format still says DVD, I think it's a mistake because the price is the...
Yup, 1080i for sure, but I can say that it *looked* like I had the output set to 720p and the Toshiba was doing the crappy scaling thing. All I have to do is switch to any other disc and there is detail galore.
I find it surprising that someone could be visibly impressed with the HD-DVD of Van Helsing. Out of the 7 or 8 titles that I've checked out so far, this is the worst. There is virtually no difference that I can see between this and the SD version. So many scenes look soft and out of focus and...
Wicked review, David. I managed to see the first episode (in hi-def) and was hooked. After stupidly missing the 2nd episode, I decided to wait until DVD, even though I'd have to settle for standard-def. I was hoping it would be similar PQ as some other great widescreen TV DVD sets (e.g...
Errr... they did mention that they were changing servers and updates would be sporadic for a while. Besides, new reviews are up there today. It's still one of my fav sites.
I normally visit DVDFile every day... and while it was often in vain throughout the last quarter of 2004, it seems to be fairly regular again - at least in terms of reviews, which is the real attraction for me. If DVDFile ever had "news", it was lost on me - I never noticed them on their site...
David, Excellent review. You're at the top of your game here. I can't express how much I enjoy and look forward to your reviews. You cover every aspect (especially AV quality) thoroughly, and I know exactly what to expect when I get the DVD in my hands. Very much appreciated. I hope you...
Great review (followed by good justification of your review standards), David - thanks, I look forward to all your excellent technical reviews. Man, I wish Disney would wake up.
Man, this is depressing. This is exactly how I felt when Ron stopped doing reviews here (and before the current reviewers started regularly posting reviews). Since there are no longer many sites that give the type of reviews I like, I have to hope that Dan and others from DVDFile will keep it...
I prefer DVDFile reviews over any other - mostly because I care about the quality of video transfer and how it comes across on a large screen. Their attention to detail is pretty good. That being said, I love David Boulet's reviews (here on this site) for the same reason. In my own DVD...
Hey David - DVDFile has backed up your PQ assessment. Haven't seen the transfer myself yet, but based on other reviews, I'm sure you're spot on and I'm going to be hugely disapointed. I'd like to boycott the DVD for this bad transfer, but I love the movie too much. Sigh...
Thanks for the heads up on the EE, David. I have a large front projection screen and I often see objectionable EE even when most reviewers don't. I think someone else hit the nail on the head when they suggested that small monitors must be used during the transfer. I just read another review...
I disagree. I don't care about an explicit list of changes. I'd rather hear about the sum of all the changes - the impact on the viewing experience as a whole - how much it felt different etc. I also care about how the transfer compares etc. So, I don't think such reviews are a waste -...
Well, I did like Underworld (I think I convinced myself to beforehand because I love the premise and Kate), but there were a couple of things that disapointed me: 1) the terrible over acting of the (hmm, forget his name) character who was left in charge of the vampires (and had a crush on...
Man... just saw this film.. and out of the 1100 DVDs I own, I think this is in the top 5 for Most Annoying Edge Enhancement. Yuck. When will the studios learn....