- View New Content
- Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads
- Home Theater Hardware
- Theaters, Remotes and Accessories
- Equipment Reviews
- DVD & Blu-ray Reviews
- Other Diversions
- Bargains and Deals
- Feedback and Testing
- Latest Blu-ray Deals
- Shop Amazon & Support HTF
- Theater Photos
DVD & Blu-ray Reviews
- Equipment Reviews
Blu-ray Release Listings
- Shop Amazon
DVD & Blu-ray Deals
Categories See All →
DVD & Blu-ray Reviews
The Other Woman Blu-ray Review
Today, 04:17 PM
A revenge comic farce of noble ambitions but erratic and often tiresome execution, Nick Cassavetes’ The Other Woman does not always make the most of its best... Read More
Mystery Science Theater 3000: Volume XXX DVD Review
Today, 01:22 PM
This 30th collection of episodes from Mystery Science Theater 3000 on DVD from Shout! Factory has some great episodes, but the special features are lacking,... Read More
Insomnia Blu-ray Review
Jul 27 2014 06:48 PM
Insomnia (1997), Director Erik Skjoldbjærg’s debut feature, is an absorbing and isolating narrative. Bright and harshly lit settings wash the dark and broodi... Read More
Need for Speed Blu-ray Review
Jul 27 2014 02:05 PM
Great car stunts and high speed street racing with a stunning array of muscle cars and super cars mostly done in real time are the reasons for the existence... Read More
Escape from Planet Earth 3D Blu-Ray Review3D Blu-ray Blu-ray
Jun 30 2013 04:40 AM | mattCR in DVD & Blu-ray Reviews
- Studio: Anchor Bay
- Distributed By: Anchor Bay
- Video Resolution: 1080P/AVC, 1080P/MVC
- Aspect Ratio: 2.39.1
- Audio: English 5.1 DTS-HDMA
- Subtitles: English, English SDH, Spanish
- Rating: PG
- Run Time: 1 Hr. 29 Min.
- Package Includes: Blu-ray, 3D Blu-ray, DVD, Digital Copy, UltraViolet
- Case Type:
- Disc Type: BD50 (dual layer), DVD-9 (dual layer)
- Region: A
- Release Date: 06/04/2013
- MSRP: $39.99
The Production Rating: 3.5/5
The storyline of Escape from Planet Earth could be thought of as taking several other movies, throwing them in a blender, and seeing what pops out. A combination of any of the Buzz Lightyear films plus Monsters Vs. Aliens and a dash of MegaMind, and you've got it. Here, Scorch (played by Brendon Frasier) a bumbling hero who is over-appreciated by his own planet and his brother, Gary (played by Rob Corddry) who is under appreciated.
Escape from Planet Earth begins with a premise and style that made me rethink how I would write this review. I knew that I wouldn't be able to fairly judge this film without kids present, so I watched the film with my two boys (13 & 12) to see what they thought. Watching an animated film with kids gives you a different perspective on it. Several of the key gags, which I thought were "OK" really worked for my 12 year old. My 13 year old was slightly outside the window of the age group that this film may attract, and both of them commented that it seemed aimed at 'younger kids'.
I think that's probably a fair assessment. Recently, in taking the kids to see "Monsters University" (which they both enjoyed), we sat through trailers and they were able to instantly pick out films they thought looked "cheap and terrible". A real endorsement for "Escape from Planet Earth" is that it doesn't fall into that category; while not an original major production from Pixar or Dreamworks, this doesn't fall into the category of completely forgettable or downright terrible.
This isn't a contender for a film that becomes an instant classic, but if you're willing to accept a generic storyline fairly well done, it accomplishes that while giving you plenty of eye candy to go with it.
Video Rating: 5/5 3D Rating: 5/5
This disc has a typical animated feel of being clean, smooth with bright and vivid colors. The unique color design and film layout is truly stunning, giving the 2D image a feel that exceeds anything I had expected. Frankly, this is a homerun that sits on par with anything from Disney, Pixar or Dreamworks in regards to the color quality and look. Presented in 1080P with the AVC CODEC at an AWBR of 33.9Mbps (Peak of 35Mbps), the presentation here is remarkable. Blacks are deep and rich, colors are presented in a way that keeps your eyes at full attention and feels inventive. This is a pleasure to watch. The characters have the smooth, blue surface that seems borrowed directly from MegaMind, but it's the light use of texture and shadowing detail that give them a form that when presented in 1080P really stands out. There are a lot of people who are going to use this disc as a reference presentation for projectors and displays.
The 3D disc kicks off with a bang; as the credits roll, snow comes falling through the screen, and breaks the black bars of the 2.39 presentation, effectively making use of a full display to add to it's 3D effect. With an AWBR of 33Mbps, this is a great looking presentation. The 3D effect seems to come and go throughout this title, but is done to great successful effect often enough to make the 3D design interesting and unique. Several effects, from shattered glass to space presentations are a lot of fun; but it is the subtle use of shadows and character movement that make the 3D in this really work for me. Throughout the film, small 3D effects are constantly within your field of vision that provide not just depth, but an extra level of unique animated detail that breathes life into these characters. This is one of the better 3D presentations I've seen, leading my oldest son to comment "the 3D is the best part".
While this will have no impact on my rating for quality, I did want to mention the DVD. A title like this really stretches MPEG2 far beyond its limits and with Escape from Planet Earth it shows. The unique texture and surfaces that help make the Blu-Ray and 3D Blu-Ray really stand out are somewhat of a detriment in the DVD presentation, they simply don't turn out well and make the characters look as though they have been through a light level blur-machine, almost as though someone using home tools put a Photoshop filter on them. The DVD strains to get the detail and image across, but I mention this DVD because it may stand out as a great disc to use if you have friends who wonder: "what is the difference, really, between Blu-Ray and DVD". A quick back and forth of this disc vs. the blu-ray clears that argument up very quickly.
Audio Rating: 5/5The opening sequence and title sequence gives you a bit of a pause in reference to audio quality. It sounds fantastic, but the music score and sound design sent my mind propelling backwards to the era of Don Bluth productions, using b-level music numbers to prop up a film. But after the original opening, I was drawn into how large the soundscape for this film remains throughout the film.
Taking full advantage of DTS-MA 5.1, Escape from Planet Earth gives you an audio stage that completely fills your room. Spaceships zoom behind you; creatures run through your livingroom, and small audio signals from computer beeps to running characters can find themselves placed anywhere in your home theater. Instead of being distracting, this sound design makes the film come alive and will be a good reason to keep this disc as a reference in your home theater.
Special Features: 2.5/5Extras are presented on the 2D Blu-Ray only. There are no extras, outside of 2 trailers, on the 3D Blu-Ray. I assume this was done in order to make sure the only content on the 3D Blu-Ray was 3D, combining the film with 2 3D Trailers. While this may be a logical choice and the direction by which studios go, I do wish they would reconsider, as the 3D disc had plenty of room for all of the extras. But even if the studio decides that the extras should remain on a 2D presentation, it makes no sense to me that the Director's commentary exists only on the 2D disc, as the 3D disc is also devoid of this audio track.
The extras as provided on the 2D Disc are:
Audio Commentary: Director Cal Brunker gives us a look at the background of the film, how it went from storyboards through production, what brought it together and issues along the way. There isn't anything in this commentary that is a real wow factor, and the director at times moves too quickly from subject to subject that I found myself lost as to the direction he was going.
The Making of Escape from Planet Earth (HD, 1080P, AC3 2.0 Audio 21:15): A pretty generic behind the scenes look at the film, interviews with cast members.
Alternate Takes & Deleted Scenes (HD, 1080P, AC3 2.0 Audio 3:53).13 deleted scenes or alternate takes from the film. These are actually all in full production, so these aren't a combination of storyboards or rough animation, instead they look like finished product that just didn't make the cut.
How to Make an Animated Feature with Director Cal Brunker (HD, 3:43):
Music Featurettes (HD, 1080P, AC3 2.0 Audio,11:10): "Shooting Star" Owl City Music Video, Delta Rae "What Matters Most,", and Cody Simpson Performs "Shine Supernova".
Also included on both discs are trailers for Hoodwinked Too and Spy Kids: All the Time in the World