Home Theater Forum › Articles › Polarization Of Consumer Projectors Lcd And Lcos

Polarization Of Consumer Projectors Lcd And Lcos

The purpose of this article is to identify the polarity or consumer level LCD and LCoS projectors.  This information can be used to identify which projectors can be best used in dual projector 3D set-ups.

 

Generally speaking, LCoS projectors will have unified polarity at 0 degrees, LCD projectors will have R&B at 0 and G at 90.  DLP will be non polarized.  Panasonic LCD projectors also seem to be depolarized, probably due to the "smooth screen" filter.

 

Model Make Polarity MSRP Native Res Lumens Contrast

Lens

Shift

Frame

Interp

Release Date Verified By
PT-AE500U Panasonic None $2,499 1280x720 850 ANSI 1300:1 None None 2004 Jan xhonzi
PT-AE2000U Panasonic None $3,499 1920x1080 1500 ANSI 16000:1 H&V   2007 Nov RBTO
HD550 JVC

All colors at 0 degrees horizontal

no circular

$4,999 1920x1080 1000 ANSI 30000:1 H&V   2009 Sep rdjam
HD950 JVC

All colors at 0 degrees horizontal

no circular

$7,999 1920x1080 900 ANSI 50000:1 H&V ? 2009 Sep rdjam
RS50 (X7) JVC

All colors at 0 degrees horizontal

no circular

$7,995 1920x1080 1300 ANSI 70000:1 H&V ? 2010 Nov GaryB from JVC UK
RS40 (X3) JVC

All colors at 0 degrees horizontal

no circular

$4,495 1920x1080 1300 ANSI 50000:1 H&V ? 2010 Nov rdjam
DLA-HD1 JVC

All colors at 0 degrees horizontal

no circular

$5,499 1920x1080 700 ANSI 15000:1 No 2007 Mar solid_dvd
PLV-Z2000 Sanyo R&B at 0 degrees, G at 90 $2,495 1920x1080 1200 ANSI 15000:1 H&V   2007 Nov xhonzi
EH-TW3500 Epson R&B at 0 degrees, G at 90    1920x1080
 
1800 ANSI 36000:1 H&V None 2009 Oct  BlackShark
PowerLite Home Cinema 8100 Epson R&B at 0 degrees, G at 90 $1,299  1920x1080
 
1800 ANSI 36000:1 H&V None 2009 Oct BlackShark
HD250 JVC ? $2,995 1920x1080 1000 ANSI 25000:1 H&V None 2010 Oct  

DLA-RS2

JVC ? $8,995 1920x1080 600 ANSI 30,000:1 H&V ? 2007 Dec  
CP-X260 Hitachi   R&B at 0 degrees, G at 90 $2,795 1024x768 2500 ANSI 500:1 None None 2006 Apr Likay
                     
                     
                     
                     
                     
                     

 

Why is this useful?

Generally speaking, you'll lose at least 50% of your lumens when going from depolarized to polarized light.  However, with wave retarders, it's possible to "rotate" the polarity of already polarized light while losing very few lumens.  The PJs that deliver full colour, completely polarized light can be used with a wave retarder to deliver the desired polarity (such as 45/135) at a minimal loss of lumens to both the screen, and the eyes of the viewer(s).

 

PJs that are either depolarized or have different colours at different angles are subject to using polarizing filters that immediately cut your lumens at least by half- and are therefore less desirable for Polarity based Dual Projector 3D set-ups.

 

For LCDs with one colour 90 degrees offset from the other two, you can buy (rather expensive) SPAR filters that retard the one colour (usually green) 90 degrees more than the other 2, effectively bringing all 3 colours into a single polarized plane.  They are not quite as efficient (to be expected) as PJs that simply project all 3 colours in a unified plane to begin with, but they are an option for LCD projectors that don't sport enough light to immediately cut 50-60% out at the first polarized filter.

 

More Information:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1280393

Comments (3)

I have been concerned and have thus put off purchase of any 3D system. Given the loss of lumen and the fact that most won't deliver a full 1090, makes we want to purchase a Mitsubishi DLP rear protjector. It's bright enough that the loss of lumens won't be as drastic and its been 3D compatible for years. That 0 gain screen for the wall will have to wait a while longer.
But, the information is valuable. Keep adding to the table and when possible delete those that are no longer sold. Also, what happens when an anamorphic lens is added?
And, I meant 1080; If we ever see a 3D system that projects two polarized 1920 x 1080 images, each progressive, but interlaced - this means really having what is referred to often as a 2k system, we can have Real3D at home whether on a projector (best and front or rear) or on 240 Hz refresh LED/LCDs or LCoS systems. Until then, I can't see anything but loss of brightness until then and I don't hold out much hope for a stunning system from Toshiba that "don't require glasses "
Home Theater Forum › Articles › Polarization Of Consumer Projectors Lcd And Lcos